Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Munshi B and Yeakub MD
Keywords : Work-life balance; Emerging economies; Women in the workforce; Organizational behavior; Societal expectations; Gender equality
This
study examines the three-way interaction between personal, organizational, and
societal factors influencing work-life balance among working women in emerging
political economies. By applying a mixed-method approach, including qualitative
interviews and quantitative surveys, this research identifies key determinants
of work-life balance in a context characterized by rapid economic and social
transformations. The findings highlight how personal ambitions, organizational
support, and societal expectations collectively shape the work-life dynamics of
women. Policy implications are discussed, aiming to guide employers and
policymakers in creating more supportive environments for working women. The
results contribute to the broader discourse on gender equality and economic
development in emerging markets.
Work-life
balance (WLB) has gained recognition as a crucial aspect over recent decades,
with scholarly acknowledgment of the benefits of helping employees achieve a
balanced life [1]. Existing literature reveals some overlooked areas [2,3],
notably the tendency to frame work-life balance as primarily a gendered issue.
The challenge of maintaining a balanced work-life for working women in
developing nations has often been overlooked [4]. This oversight is
significant, especially as evidence indicates that women in these regions face
more pronounced work-life balance challenges than men due to socio-cultural
conflicts [5]. In such environments, women typically take on exclusive
responsibilities for parenting, caregiving, and domestic chores, while also
confronting discrimination in patriarchal societies [6]. Balancing work and
life in these conditions becomes increasingly challenging for women. The rise
of globalization has led to more women entering the workforce, resulting in a
higher number of dual-earner households [7]. Consequently, women may find
themselves with less time to manage their multiple roles [8]. The simultaneous
demands of various roles, coupled with limited support from family and
government, create obstacles such as stress, failure, and burnout for employees
[9]. The current research, therefore, aims to explore how perceived stress and
person-organization fit (POF) influence the work-life balance of protean
career-oriented (PCO) women in a developing country.
PCO
is a framework that helps recognize the careers of modern employees,
positioning them as architects of their professional fates. PCO emphasizes the
pursuit of career success through self-managed career development. It
encompasses two main approaches: a self-directed approach, where individuals
actively manage their career progression by making autonomous career decisions
and exploring options; and a value-driven approach, where individuals pursue
goals and values that are personally significant, guiding their career
decisions and contributing to their sense of fulfillment. WLB is crucial for
most employees as it significantly affects their professional satisfaction.
Therefore, it is essential to understand the interplay between PCO and WLB,
especially from the perspective of the conservation of resources (COR) theory,
which posits that individuals strive to maintain and acquire new resources to
avert stress [9]. This study aims to assess the relationship between PCO and
WLB by examining professional outcomes like POF and perceived stress. The study
adds to existing research in several ways. It is the first to investigate POF
as a moderating factor in the relationship between PCO and WLB. Additionally,
it focuses on female employees in the telecommunications sector of Pakistan, a
relatively understudied demographic. A novel aspect of this research is the
exploration of a three-way interaction among perceived stress,
person-organization fit, and PCO, thus examining how these factors collectively
influence work-life balance. This study is structured as follows: an
introduction, review of past literature, followed by a detailed methodology
section including sample, research design, and measures used. Subsequently, it
presents the results, discussions, and managerial implications derived from the
findings.
Conservation
of resources (COR) theory posits assets to be dynamisms, conditions and,
individual features which people prize as assets help in achieving individual
goals. Resources can be personal, within the character, or circumstantial,
outside the character. Resources can be unstable or robust. Acquiring
individual assets such as information, positive mood, self-efficiency and
skills allows for employees to achieve positive consequences, such as positive
attitude and improved enactment, at home as well as at work. The COR concept
validates that motivated individuals retain their resources. COR theory adopts
that a resource gain spiral is established, as people who attain resources are
able to generate and obtain additional resources, which helps them improve
their performance [10-16]. The current research adopted COR theory as it will
help understand how career-oriented women acquire resources which will enable
them to strive a balanced work-life.
Protean
career orientation (PCO) and work-life balance (WLB)
PCO
refers to an individual taking complete charge over his career path [21]. When
individuals become agents of their destiny they try to acquire resources that
will help them grow in their career [22]. Work-life balance is attained when a
worker is satisfied with the career progress along with other life
responsibilities. Since balance is contingent on gratification in numerous
functions and assets are required to achieve satisfaction. COR perspective [17]
provides conceptual lens to examine relationship of PCO with WLB.
Individuals
who pursue a protean career strive to create both external alongside internal
resources to attain significant targets. Individuals with high PCO explore
career options proactively, along with acquiring resources [18-20]. They
navigate their own career development with the help of internal resources, such
as having a meaningful life [25]. Navigating their own career development will
help individuals meet demands of various domain of life and facilitate
work-life balance [22]. Individuals with PCO achieve good work-life balance
[22-24]. Moreover, PCO employees need to plan their career and establish
targets in order to achieve an acceptable equilibrium amid professional and
personal life. Hence, it is expected that PCO will significantly impact WLB
(H1).
Hypothesis
1: There is a significant relationship between protean career orientation and
work life balance.
Moderating
role of perceived stress
Perceived
stress is the extent of frustration of a specific event, with the impact of a
characteristics of a person’s personality, capacity to deal with
stress-stimulating indicators and surroundings [26,27]. Working women, bare
more stress as they deal with managing multiple responsibilities such as
looking after, kids, work and home [28]. When they manage so many
responsibilities simultaneously, it leads to work-family spillover, making
anxiety and stress permanent ally.
Occupational stress causes difficulties and forces women to give up work
and concentrate more on family [29], which causes an imbalance in work-life.
Mostly people experience perceived stress in their lives and that interferes
with maintaining a balanced life. Perceived stress, according to this
perspective, has been considered an undesirable measure of the quality of life
of a person. Therefore, it is assumed that if there is low stress among women
employees, the primary relationship between PCO and WLB holds. Alternatively,
if there is high level of stress the primary relationship does not hold, as all
the resources will be dampened due to stress. Hence, the following hypothesis
is proposed.
Hypothesis
2: The significant relationship between protean career orientation and work
life balance is moderated by perceived stress, such that the relationship is
weaker at higher levels of perceived stress.
Moderating
role of person-organization fit
POF
is regarded as a vital concept in guaranteeing that the work-life quality of
employees is safeguarded by augmenting their productivity and decreasing the
rate of turnover. It was revealed that people who seek employment experience
high POF for firms that substitute typical salaries with work-life balance in
staffing constituents. On the flipside, workers sense low POF for firms that
substitute standard pay with health reimbursements. Being consistent with POF perception,
equilibrium in work-life and fit insight leads to workers experiencing
decreased balance alongside an increase in stress when there is a nonconformist
amid the reserves to deal with the burdens from the external setting.
Once
a career-oriented employee gets access to better resources and along with that
has achieved a good fit with the organization, the employee gets the chance to
attain equilibrium in their work-life. On the other hand, if an employee is
career oriented but the organization fit is not achieved, the employee will
suffer at the hands of the misfit with the organization [30-36]. In this case,
employee will not be able to achieve balanced work-life. Hence, we propose that
workers who are content with their career and sense POF achieve their WLB
better (H3).
Hypothesis
3: The significant relationship between protean career orientation and work
life balance is moderated by person organization fit, such that the
relationship is stronger at higher levels of person organization fit.
While
a positive impact is predicted of PCO on WLB, there are exogenous enabling and
constraining factors. Despite the potential of protean career-oriented women to
acquire resources and utilize those resources to achieve a balanced work-life,
there might be disruption in that relation due to high level of stress and low
person organization fit. Stress may act as an undermining factor while POF will
potentially strengthen the relationship as discussed above. However, these two
factors may interact. For example, an employee who is experiencing high stress,
low POF may experience double impact on the primary relationship (PCO with
WLB). The low POF may induce further stress [37]. Hence, the positive benefits
of POC on WLB maybe be lost due to the high stress, low POF and the special
effect that low POF may have on stress.
Women
in developing countries, like Pakistan, suffer from stress and pressure due to
the unfair distribution of family and child’s responsibilities [4]. Fit
perception speculates employees suffering from imbalance in work-life [35],
alongside an increased strain wherein there exists a nonconformist amid the
resources to deal with stresses from work settings. In light of these hurdles,
the research considered two contingencies that might influence the baseline
relationship between PCO and WLB:
perceived stress and person-organization fit. Hence it is concluded that
both perceived stress and person organization fit moderates the relationship of
PCO and WLB (H4).
Hypothesis
4: The significant interaction effect between protean career orientation and
person organization fit on work life balance is moderated by perceived stress,
such that this interaction effect is weaker at higher levels of perceived
stress.
The relationship between protean career orientation and work-life balance is being studied by considering two moderators, including person organization fit and perceived stress. The research focuses on considering each moderator separately and later on exploring the three-way interaction of protean career orientation, POF and perceived stress on work-life balance. Hence, the following conceptual model is suggested (Figure 1).
Figure
1: Theoretical Framework.
Sample
and data collection
Women
respondents were selected from the telecommunication industry. Minimum sample
of 200 responses was proposed [38-40]. Out of the 373 responses gathered, 352
were considered to be utilizable. The response rate came out to be 94.36%.
Current research used self-administered and online surveys which have been used
by many researchers earlier [22]. Location and geographical area selected for
data collection included Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad, the three major cities of
Pakistan. Telecommunication firms like Mobilink, Ufone and Warid, were
contacted and upon asking for consent from the managerial staff, conduction of
the surveys took place. Further, within the companies, an online questionnaire
was distributed, and an online survey was conducted since it allows for ease in
data accumulation alongside cost reduction. Moreover, in comparison to
traditional paper surveys, online surveys have a higher response rate.
A
five-point Likert scale was used to measure all indicators, where higher values
represented agreement. Respondents were instructed to rate the degree to which
they represented their situation in their organization, ranging from 1 =
strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree. A three-item scale was used to measure
protean career orientation (PCO). The items were adapted from Baruch and
Yehuda, (2014). Sample item includes “I take responsibility for my own
development” [41]. A three-item scale was used to measure person organization
fit (POF). The items were adapted from Valentine et al., (2002). Sample item
includes “I feel that my personal values are a good fit with this organization”
[42].
A
three-item scale was used to measure work-life balance (WLB). The items were
replicated from Shukla et al, 2016. Sample item includes “Sample question is,
“I am able to balance between time at work and time at other activities” [43].
A four-item scale was used to measure perceived stress (PS). The items were
adapted from Cohen, (1983). Sample item includes “In the last month, how often
have you felt that you were unable to control important things in life?” [27].
Composite
reliability (CR) was used to compute the core dependability of the latent
constructs. CR value was higher than 0.7 for all the constructs as shown below
in table 1 as proposed by Hair [44].
Confirmatory
factor analysis was conducted to test the model. Additionally, convergent
validity was also tested with the help of average variance extracted (AVE). It
usually holds when AVE is greater than 0.5 [45]. AVE was greater than 0.5 for
all the variables.
The
current research, tested hypotheses in four interlinked steps. Firstly, the
direct relationship between PCO with WLB was studied with the help of
regression analysis (H1). In this model work-life balance was specified as
dependent variable, while the control variables (age, monthly income and
education of female employees) were added as predictor variables and PCO was
considered as the independent variable. Secondly the moderator, person
organization fit (POF) was also added in the model (H2). Thirdly, the second
moderator, perceived stress was also added in the model (H3). Fourthly, the
three-way interaction between PCO, perceived stress (PS) and person
organization fit (POF) was also evaluated in the model (H4). In order to understand the effects of
moderation and three-way interaction, PROCESS model was used in SPSS software
[46].
Model
3 denotes two interacting moderators, was specified, where protean career
orientation was exogenous variable, work-life balance was endogenous variable,
perceived stress was first moderating variable and person organization fit was
specified as the second moderating variable.
Table
2 shows the descriptive statistics and correlations and table 3 shows the
regression results. The model included three control variables, age, education
and monthly income. The model studies the three-way interaction (Protean career
orientation x perceived stress x person-organization fit) along with its
underlying two-way interactions. (Tables 1-3) depicts in support of hypothesis
1, that protean career orientation significantly impacts work-life balance (? =
5.394, p < .01). The results also depict that perceived stress moderates the
relationship between work-life balance and protean career orientation (? = -
1.424, p < .001). Hence it supports hypothesis 2. Hypothesis 3 stated that
person-organization fit moderates the relationship between work-life balance
and protean career orientation, it was supported by the results (? = - 1.5095,
p < .001). Hence the results support the attenuating effect of perceived
stress (? = - 1.424, p < .001) and the invigorating effect of person
organization fit (? = - 1.5095, p < .001) on PCO and WLB relationship. Thus,
effectiveness of protean career-oriented women as means of balancing work-life
is greater when women exhibit lower perceived stress (hypothesis 2) and they
experience higher person-organization fit (hypothesis 3). To clarify the nature
of these interactions, graphs were plotted to show the effects of PCO on WLB
for high and low levels of perceived stress and POF in (Figures 2),
respectively, combined with a simple slope analysis for each [47,48]. The
results in Figure 2 indicate that the relationship between PCO and WLB is
significant as perceived stress moderates the relationship (t = -3.7030, p =
< 0.001), Similarly, the same figure indicates that the relationship between
PCO and WLB is significant with POF as a moderator (t = -3.6314, p = <
0.001). Lastly, it indicates a significant moderation of the three-way
interaction of PCO x PS x POF (t = 4.3190, p = < 0.001).
Hypothesis 4 was also supported and accepted as the three-way interaction between PCO, POF and perceived stress came out to be significant (? = .4122, p < .001).
Figure 2: Three-way interaction between Protean career orientation, person organization fit and perceived stress.
This study adds to the theoretical perceptive by contributing to the research of WLB as it elaborates on how two critical factors (person organization fit and perceived stress) impact career-oriented women trying to achieve a balanced life. The lack of pervious attention given to working women trying to achieve a balanced life is surprising. The novel idea of how stress aggravates the situation of women in developing country, who are already under a lot of pressure due to the social and cultural norms [28], highlights the importance of studying this phenomenon. Perceived stress refers to an individual’s perception of the degree of stressfulness in their lives and their subsequent capacity to deal with the resulting anxiety. On the other hand, POF means that there is good congruence between the person’s abilities and the organization [49-53]. It was posited that perceived stress challenges the positive relationship between protean career-oriented women and work-life balance, however POF enhances the relationship.
Table 1: Confirmatory Factor Analysis.
Table 2: Means, Standard Deviations, and Correlations.
The study researched about the impact of protean career orientation on work-life balance while considering two moderators, perceived stress and person organization fit. The sample was taken from women employees working in telecommunication sector. The study concluded that protean career orientation has a significant impact on work life balance of women employees in the telecommunication sector (H1).
Table 3: Regression Results (Dependent Variable: Work Life Balance).
The
result is supported by extant literature, as it is proved that career oriented
(self-motivated) employees make deliberate effort to maintain a balanced work
life [22]. However, in emerging economies like Pakistan, women bare all the
burden of household responsibilities hence, women are more likely to have
stress when trying to accomplish multiple roles [4]. There were two moderators
included in the model; perceived stress and person organization fit; they were
studied between the relationship of protean career orientation and work life
balance. The second hypothesis, discussed perceived stress as a moderator
between protean career orientation and work life balance. The results concluded
that perceived stress did moderate the relationship of PCO and WLB. This was
another contribution of the current research. The studies suggest that women
bare all the burden of household responsibilities and various role demands
coexistence along with limited support from family and government creates
hurdles e.g. stress, failure and burnout [9]. This suggested that stress is
caused due to societal pressures in women particularly in emerging economies
like Pakistan. Hence the results also suggested that stress does moderate the
relationship of PCO and WLB (H2). Another moderator considered was POF; it was
concluded that a career oriented (self-motivated) person balances his/her life
better only if they achieve a good fit with the organization (H3). Another
contribution to the study was that three-way interaction of (PCO x perceived
stress x POF) and its impact on WLB was gauged (H4). The results came out to be
significant of the three-way interaction as it showed that career-oriented
women experience stress and fatigue but if they manage to achieve a good fit
with the organization, they can achieve a balanced life.
Theoretical implications
The
study contributes to the past literature in numerous ways. It extends the
research on work-life balance by testing the relationship between PCO and WLB
in the presence of two moderators; person organization fit and perceived
stress. In consistent with the past literature, the research provides empirical
evidence that person organization fit and perceived stress moderate the
relationship of PCO and WLB. The relationship of PCO and WLB was studied
beforehand; nevertheless, a gap exists for when it comes to assessing the
influence of person organization fit and perceived stress on work-life balance,
especially in women employees’ working in telecommunication sector in Pakistan.
By introducing two moderators between the relationship of PCO and WLB, researchers
can gain insight about how women live a balanced life along with trying to
maintain a fit with the organization and carrying the burden of stress.
Managerial implications
The
study suggests from a practical perspective that managers should encourage
women employees who are self-driven and self-motivated to achieve a balanced
life. To achieve this, HR managers will have to come up with strategies to give
comfort to women in the organization. They will have to reward on
productivity-based work employees do within the organization, that will help
reduce the stress of women employees. It is very important for the managers to
help hire women employees who are career oriented and have a good fit with
organizational goals. That will help the organization have motivated employees
who manage good balance in work-life. PCO is associated with the acquisition of
resources (e.g. person organization fit). People should acknowledge the advantages
of implementing the self-directed approach for handling their jobs. A solid PCO
can be attained by careful analysis of one’s profession alongside the aid of
developmental relationships. For example, managers could help subordinates in
the latter cultivating their own explanation of what it means to have a
successful career alongside developing practical approaches to achieve personal
targets.
Many
informal and formal policies exist that could help in attaining better
work-life balance for employees of that organization. Informal policies include
family-supportive organizational cultures and supervision, and formal policies
comprise ?exibility policies. Together, both formal and informal policies allow
for a reduction in conflicts revolving around work family conflicts, which
would eventually lead to a balanced work-life. Consequently, business schools
should acknowledge that they have a considerable influence on how enrolled
students choose their career paths in a self-direct (protean) manner so as to
accomplish their job goals and lead a balanced life. Institutions can assist
students by providing opportunities for them to develop a proactive approach
toward the development of their careers, learn what it is like to work in a
practical setting, and simultaneously gain an understanding of their values.
Career management coursework, small group workshops, individual career
counselling, and internships and organizational experiences through education
work assignments can all be used to provide such opportunities.
Some
limitations to the existing current study comprise the fact that data has been
gathered from the telecommunication industry only which has led to the results
only being applicable for that respective industry. It is advised that future
studies include the relation between PCO with other job and professions, for
instance, subjective and objective career success, job engagement, and
different career planning behaviors. Employment-related resources, such as
individuality, may interact with motivational factors such as felt duty for
dependents, to anticipate workers' work-life balance. Evidently, future studies
should include such motivators and career-related resources to evaluate the
accomplishment of a balanced life. Furthermore, this study has only concentrated
on the favorable outcomes of PCO. Future research should look into what occurs
when self-motivated workers fail to meet their objectives. The negative effect
of PCO on a person's character is yet to be studied. The study should also look
into the effects of PCO on part-time workers, as their work-life balance will
differ from that of full-time workers.