Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Storrer CLM, Madalena IR, Lara RM, Omori MA, Schroeder A, Nelson-Filho P, Baratto-Filho F, Andrades KMR, Proff P, Küchler EC, and Kirschneck C
Keywords : Bone loss; Estrogen; Periodontal disease
Microorganisms of the subgingival biofilm are
associated with periodontal inflammation and its progression involves
interactions between host inflammatory and immune system and pathogenic
microbiota [1]. Periodontal diseases are complex diseases that should be
treated based on their multifactorial nature and variability identifying some
risk factors, such as lifestyle, medication, and systemic conditions [2,3],
such as hormonal imbalance [4].
Estrogen is a widely studied hormone that is known to
play a substantial role in inhibiting bone resorption [5] and
stimulating bone formation, thus leading to a steady or slightly increased bone
mineral density [6]. Estrogen-deficiency (hypoestrogenism) induces expression
of receptor activator of nuclear factor kappaB ligand (RANKL) and decreases the
level of osteoprotegerin, causing increased osteoclastogenesis [7]. Endogenous
levels of estrogen can change according to age and gender [8]. For instance,
during puberty, there is an increase in estrogen levels [9]. Hypoestrogenism
can appear naturally after menopause [10,11], but may also occur during the
pubertal stage in some conditions [12-17]. In animal models, bilateral
ovariectomy is a common procedure to stimulate hypoestrogenism [18].
Previous works have shown that hypoestrogenism in
adulthood may increase alveolar bone loss [3,7,19-21], negatively influencing
the periodontium and alveolar bone resorption, leading to a tooth loss in rats
[11] and human studies [22]. Considering the important role of estrogen during
female puberty, in this study we evaluated, if hypoestrogenism during puberty
impacts alveolar bone loss.
Sample normality was analyzed by Shapiro-Wilk tests. Comparative analysis was performed by Student’s t-tests to verify the difference in the measurements between hypoestrogenism and control groups. The results were presented as means and standard deviations (SDs). Statistical significance was assumed at p ? 0.05. All analyses were performed using the Prism 8 software (Graph Pad Software Inc., San Diego, California, USA).
Figure 1: Three-dimensional view of the mandibular right first molar. Linear measurements of alveolar bone loss (CEJ to ABC) at the lingual site. D R- distal root; MD R- medial root and MS R- mesial root.
Figure 2: Flow chart of the experiment.
The Figure 2 demonstrated the flowchart, 5
rats died before recovering from anesthesia, therefore, 8 rats from
the hypoestrogenism group and 11 rats from the control group were included in
the morphometric analysis. Results of bone loss (CEJ-ABC) from the CT
analysis in hypoestrogenism and in control groups and the comparison between
groups are presented in (Figure 3).
At the lingual site, a statistically significance difference between the groups at the medial root was found (p=0.04): in the hypoestrogenism group the CEJ-ABC mean was 0.57mm (SD = 0.14), while in the control group the CEJ-ABC mean was 0.46mm (SD = 0.07). At the linguo-distal root, a statistically significance difference between groups (p=0.04) was observed as well: in the hypoestrogenism group the CEJ-ABC mean was 0.39mm (SD = 0.10), while in the control group the mean was 0.28mm (SD = 0.11). At the buccal area, a statistically significant difference was found between groups (p=0.05). At the medial root: in the hypoestrogenism group, the CEJ-ABC mean was 1.45mm (SD= 0.30), while in the control group the CEJ-ABC mean was 1.23mm (SD = 0.17).
Figure 3: Alveolar bone loss (CEJ-ABC) according to the groups at the different measurement sites. * means statistically significant difference between groups (p ? 0.05).
During
the past decades, studies using rat models have been used to investigate
periodontitis progression during estrogen-deficiency (hypoestrogenism)
conditions. These were postmenopausal osteoporosis models and the results from
these experiments increased our knowledge on the important role of the estrogen
as a protective factor for alveolar bone loss [7,19]. Although many previous
studies [3,7,19-21] evaluated the relationship between
hypoestrogenism and alveolar bone loss in rodents (adult rats), our study
differs from previous ones, since it focused on the pubertal stage. In humans,
hypoestrogenism in young patients were reported in chromosomal conditions [12],
in girls with hormonal alterations [13], including ovarian problems [14] also
in undernourishments individuals [15], adolescent athlete with exercise-induced
amenorrhea [16] and patients under chemotherapy treatment [17]. Therefore, we
conducted an in vivo study in female rodents to investigate,
whether hypoestrogenism in the
pubertal period could impact on alveolar bone loss at molars.
The nature of the connection between periodontal
disease and hypoestrogenism-induced bone loss is not completely understood.
Anbinder et al. [20] reported that hypoestrogenism cannot be considered alone
as a factor involved in the risk for alveolar bone amount or loss [19]. In our
study, however, we observed that estrogen-deficiency during puberty is involved
in alveolar bone loss in young ages without the experimental periodontitis
induction. A possible lack of association between hypoestrogenism and alveolar
bone loss observed in previous studies without the induction of experimental
periodontitis might be due to the type of analysis performed and the age/period
of the rats. In our study, with µCT analysis, we performed a more reliable
analysis. µCT-based measurements have the advantage of high resolution and the
ability to determine alveolar bone loss by 3D assessment.
Other studies using estrogen-deficient animals [7,21]
have revealed that the osteoporosis resulting from estrogen-deficiency
increases alveolar bone resorption in rats with and without ligature-induced
periodontitis. The lack of estrogen induces a significant inequality in bone
remodeling with bone resorption surpassing bone formation. Main characteristics
of the osteoporosis induced are reduced bone mass and mineral content,
alterations in bone micro?architecture and higher risk of fractures [26]. As an
effect of the rising osteoporosis prevalence, clinicians and researchers from
different fields have focused on studying the impact of hypoestrogenism on
different bone pathologies, including the periodontal condition.
Briefly, the main power of our study is that it
provides preliminary data demonstrating the
influence of estrogen-deficiency in the pubertal stage on alveolar bone. General dentists, orthodontists,
pediatric dentists, and periodontists must be aware of the consequences of
hypoestrogenism in dental practice.
The authors gratefully
thanks to RCBE (Regensburg Center of Biomedical Engineering) for the support by
the Micro-computed
tomography facility. We also acknowledge the Deutsche
Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) in frame of the program “Forschungsgeräte” (INST
102/11 – 1 FUGG) support. The São Paulo Research Foundation
(FAPESP) (2015/06866-5), the Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível
Superior - Brasil (CAPES) - Finance Code 001 and the
Alexander-von-Humboldt-Foundation (Küchler/Kirschneck accepted in July 4th,
2019) also provided financial support.