Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Chinedu-Elonu PO, and Uroegbulam Favour C
Keywords : Health promotion; Education; Dental health; Secondary school students; Imo state
This study evaluates the effectiveness of school-based
health education programs on dental health among secondary school students in
Imo State, Nigeria. A cross-sectional research design was employed, involving
270 students from three secondary school levels (SS1, SS2, and SS3). The aim
was to assess students' dental health knowledge, attitudes, and practices
before and after the intervention. The findings revealed significant
improvements in students' dental health knowledge, with a marked increase in the
understanding of factors contributing to tooth decay, such as eating sugary
foods (67.7%), not brushing teeth (73.7%), and poor dental care habits (62.6%).
After the program, 67.0% of students felt more knowledgeable about dental
health, and 74.4% acknowledged the importance of regular dental visits.
Moreover, students reported improved dental hygiene behaviours, with 44.1%
brushing twice a day (up from 35.2% before the intervention) and 55.9% flossing
regularly (a significant increase from pre-intervention levels). The percentage
of students who never brushed their teeth decreased from 13.0% to 6.3%. Despite
these positive outcomes, challenges such as inadequate time for health
education sessions (37.4%), limited resources (29.3%), and lack of parental involvement
(34.4%) were identified as barriers to the program’s effectiveness. Cultural
beliefs around dental health, affecting 18.9% of students, also posed a
challenge. In conclusion, the study highlights the positive impact of
school-based health education on improving students' dental health knowledge
and practices. However, to maximize effectiveness, it is recommended to
increase interactive sessions, collaborate with dental professionals, and
enhance parental involvement. Future studies should explore ways to overcome
cultural barriers and evaluate the long-term impact of these health education
programs. This research contributes to the growing body of knowledge on
school-based health interventions, particularly in the context of oral health
promotion.
Dental health has increasingly been recognized as
equally important to general health, particularly due to its significant impact
on overall well-being. Dental caries and gingival diseases, prevalent among school-age
children, affect approximately 80% of this demographic globally [1]. These
conditions cause pain and tooth loss, adversely impacting appearance,
nutritional intake, quality of life, growth, and development [2].The cost of
neglecting dental health is considerable, encompassing personal discomfort,
financial burden, and social consequences. Despite the preventability of these
diseases through simple dental hygiene practices, there remains a notable gap
in knowledge among children, their caregivers, and policymakers about effective
preventive measures. Thus, prevention has become a cornerstone of modern dental
practice [3]. Health promotion aims to empower individuals to manage and
improve their health effectively. Dental health education (DHE) plays a crucial
role in this domain, serving as a fundamental component of dental health
services. The objective of DHE is to provide information that enhances dental
health knowledge, fosters healthier lifestyles, and encourages positive
attitudes and behaviours through educational means [4]. Effective health
promotion in schools can significantly enhance dental health status by
targeting children during their formative years, a period crucial for
establishing lifelong health-related attitudes and behaviours [5]. School-based
dental health education involves various strategies, including publicity
campaigns, classroom talks, dental health films, and integrated programs within
school curricula [6]. Factors critical for effective DHE include the repetition
and reinforcement of dental hygiene instructions, which have shown positive
short-term and long-term effects [7]. The school environment is particularly
influential during preadolescence and adolescence, a time when children are
more receptive to adopting health-related behaviours that often persist into
adulthood [8]. Schools are considered an ideal setting for delivering DHE,
where dental health promotion can be integrated with preventive services to
achieve better outcomes. Globally, schools have been recognized as effective
environments for delivering DHE, improving dental hygiene, and enhancing dental
health knowledge and behaviours [9]. A school-based approach has been reported
to be more cost-effective and efficient compared to community-based methods for
delivering preventive and curative services [10].
Modern DHE programs often employ a combination of
methods, including lectures, demonstrations, visual aids, and interactive tools
such as video presentations and supervised brushing sessions [11]. Traditional
educational aids, such as lectures and models, have demonstrated limited or
short-term effectiveness. Contemporary approaches incorporate interactive
elements to create a more engaging learning experience and promote sustained
dental health habits among children [12]. Given the importance of dental health
education in shaping long-term health behaviours, this study aims to evaluate
the effectiveness of school-based health education programs on dental health
among secondary school students. By assessing various educational interventions
and their impact on dental health knowledge, practices, and outcomes, this
research seeks to identify best practices for enhancing dental health promotion
in school settings [13]. Dental health among secondary school students is a
critical public health issue that requires urgent attention. Despite the
growing recognition of the importance of dental health, a significant number of
school-aged children continue to suffer from dental conditions such as dental
caries and gingival diseases. These conditions, which affect approximately 80%
of school-going children globally, lead to considerable pain, tooth loss, and
negative impacts on appearance, nutritional intake, quality of life, growth,
and development. The neglect of dental health has substantial personal,
financial, and social consequences, yet many children, their caregivers, and
policymakers remain unaware of effective preventive measures [14]. Preventive
dental care is crucial, as dental diseases are largely preventable through
straightforward, self-managed oral hygiene practices. However, the lack of
awareness and proper education regarding these practices contributes to the
persistence of dental health issues. The existing gap in dental health
knowledge among secondary school students highlights the need for effective
educational interventions that promote better oral hygiene and preventive
behaviours [15]. School-based dental health education (DHE) programs have the
potential to address these issues by integrating dental health promotion within
the school environment. However, there is a need to evaluate the effectiveness
of various school-based DHE strategies to ensure they effectively improve
dental health knowledge and practices among students. While traditional educational
methods have been used, there is evidence suggesting that contemporary,
interactive approaches may yield more significant and sustained improvements in
dental health behaviours [16]. Therefore, this study aims to evaluate the
effectiveness of different school-based DHE programs in enhancing dental health
among secondary school students. The focus will be on assessing the impact of
these programs on students' dental health knowledge, attitudes, and practices,
and identifying the most effective methods for promoting long-term dental
health in this critical age group.
Research design
This study employs a cross-sectional research design
to evaluate the effectiveness of school-based health education programs on
dental health among secondary school students in Imo State.
Study area
The study took place in Imo State but for focus; we
study Owerri Municipal, Imo State, Nigeria. Owerri Municipal is a Local
Government Area in Imo State, Nigeria with coordinates 5.4682° N, 7.0176° E.
Its headquarters is in the city of Owerri. It has an area of 58 km² and a
population of 127,213 according to the 2006 census. Owere town was and still is
today made up of five villages namely – Umuororonjo, Amawom, Umuonyeche, Umuodu
and Umuoyima (collectively known as Owerri Nchi Ise).It is also the trade
center for palm products, corn , yams and cassava. Eke Ukwu Owere market is the
main market in Owerri Municipal. For the purpose of this study; Methodist High
School Ikenegbu is used as a focus. It is chosen because it is a mixed school;
so, both boys and girls can be captured as well good coordination during the
study. Methodist High School Ikenegbu is a co-educational faith based secondary
school situated at Ikenegbu, Owerri. It offers the best in secondary education.
Staffed with competent teachers, it has become famous for winning laurels in
school competitions and excellence in WASSCE and NECO Exams. In accordance with
the Nigerian National Policy on Education, the school runs a six-year programme
which is divided into two sections: The Junior Secondary School (JSS) - which
lasts for three years, and The Senior Secondary School (SSS) - which lasts for
three years.
Study population
The population for the study were the senior secondary
school students of Methodist High School Ikenegbu between the ages of 13–18
year above. According to the school register of 2023; there are about 800
students from SSI to SS3.
Instrument for data
collection
The primary instrument for data collection was a
structured questionnaire designed to assess students' knowledge, attitudes, and
practices regarding dental health. The questionnaire include sections on
demographic information, current dental health practices, awareness of dental
health issues, and attitudes towards oral hygiene.
Validity of instrument
To ensure the validity of the instrument, the
questionnaire was reviewed by project supervisor. The feedback was used to make
necessary adjustments to ensure that the questions accurately measure the
intended constructs related to dental health.
Reliability of
instrument
The reliability of the questionnaire was tested using
a pilot study conducted with a sample of 30 students from a different school
not included in the main study. The internal consistency of the questionnaire
was assessed using Cronbach’s alpha, with a threshold of 0.70 considered
acceptable for reliability.
Method
of Data Collection
Data were collected through self-administered
questionnaires distributed to students in the selected schools. The data
collection process will be conducted over a period of two weeks.
Method
of Data Analysis
Quantitative data analysis was performed using
statistical software such as SPSS. Descriptive statistics, including mean,
standard deviation, and frequency distributions, was used to summarize the
data. Inferential statistics, such as paired t-tests and chi-square tests, were
employed to assess changes in knowledge, attitudes, and practices before and
after the intervention.
Ethical
Consideration
The study will adhere to ethical standards for research involving human subjects. Approval will be obtained from the relevant ethics review board. Informed consent will be obtained from students and their parents or guardians. Participants will be assured of the confidentiality of their responses and the voluntary nature of their participation. All data will be anonymized and stored securely to protect participants' privacy.
Demographic information
The demographic distribution of the sample is
relatively balanced across key categories. Among the 270 respondents, the
largest age group is 15-17 years (36.0%), followed by the 12-14 years group
(27.0%). The remaining respondents are in the 18-20 years (20.4%) and 21 and
above (16.6%) categories. Gender distribution is perfectly even, with 50% males
and 50% females, suggesting a balanced representation across genders. Regarding
class/grade, 33% of students are in SS1, 33.7% in SS2, and 33.3% in SS3,
indicating that all three school levels are well-represented (Table 1).
Dental health knowledge,
attitudes, and practices (before health education program)
The data reveals that dental health knowledge among
students is mixed before the implementation of the health education program. A
significant majority, 67.7%, acknowledge that eating sugary foods contributes
to tooth decay, and 73.7% understand that not brushing teeth is a major cause
of dental issues. However, awareness about other factors such as drinking too
much soda (55.9%) and poor dental care habits (62.6%) is somewhat lower. The
majority of students (50.7%) are aware of dental plaque, but nearly half
(49.3%) are not. Regarding brushing habits, 35.2% of students brush their teeth
twice a day, while 31.5% brush once a day. However, a concerning 13.0% of
students reported that they never brush their teeth, indicating room for improvement.
Less than half of the respondents (44.8%) have ever visited a dentist,
highlighting a gap in dental care-seeking behaviour (Table 2).
Impact
of school-based health education programs (post-implementation)
After the implementation of the school-based health
education program, there is a marked improvement in dental health knowledge and
attitudes. A large majority (67.0%) feel more knowledgeable about dental
health, with 74.4% recognizing the importance of visiting the dentist.
Furthermore, 70.7% of students report feeling more confident in maintaining
good dental hygiene, and 78.1% have changed their attitude towards brushing and
flossing. This is reflected in behavioural changes, with 44.1% of students now
brushing twice a day, and 55.9% flossing regularly. Interestingly, the
proportion of students who never brush their teeth has decreased significantly
to just 6.3%. These results suggest that the health education program has
successfully improved both knowledge and practices related to dental health (Table
3).
Engagement
in preventive dental care practices
The results on preventive dental care practices show some positive changes following the program. A considerable number of students (44.1%) now visit the dentist occasionally for check-ups or treatment, while 27.0% visit regularly, indicating an increase in dental care-seeking behaviour. Additionally, a majority (73.7%) now use fluoride toothpaste, which is considered an important preventive measure for dental health. However, 28.9% of students still do not visit the dentist, and 26.3% are not using fluoride toothpaste, pointing to some gaps in ongoing preventive care practices (Table 4).
Table 1: Demographic Information.
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
Age |
12-14 |
73 |
27.0% |
15-17 |
97 |
36.0% |
|
18-20 |
55 |
20.4% |
|
21 and above |
45 |
16.6% |
|
Gender |
Male |
135 |
50.0% |
Female |
135 |
50.0% |
|
Class/Grade |
SS1 |
89 |
33.0% |
SS2 |
91 |
33.7% |
|
SS3 |
90 |
33.3% |
Table 2: Dental Health Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices (Before Health Education Program).
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
How
often do you brush your teeth? |
Once a day |
85 |
31.5% |
Twice a day |
95 |
35.2% |
|
Less than once a day |
55 |
20.4% |
|
Never |
35 |
13.0% |
|
Do you
know what dental plaque is? |
Yes |
137 |
50.7% |
No |
133 |
49.3% |
|
What
do you think causes tooth decay? (Check all that
apply) |
Eating sugary foods |
183 |
67.7% |
Not brushing teeth |
199 |
73.7% |
|
Drinking too much soda |
151 |
55.9% |
|
Poor dental care habits |
169 |
62.6% |
|
What
is the recommended duration for brushing your teeth? |
1-2 minutes |
91 |
33.7% |
3-4 minutes |
81 |
30.0% |
|
5 minutes |
61 |
22.6% |
|
I do not know |
37 |
13.7% |
|
Have
you ever visited a dentist? |
Yes |
121 |
44.8% |
No |
149 |
55.2% |
Table 3: Impact of School-Based Health Education Programs (Post-Implementation).
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
Do you feel more knowledgeable about dental health? |
Yes |
181 |
67.0% |
No |
89 |
33.0% |
|
Do you understand the importance of visiting the dentist? |
Yes |
201 |
74.4% |
No |
69 |
25.6% |
|
Do you feel more confident in your ability to maintain good dental
hygiene? |
Yes |
191 |
70.7% |
No |
79 |
29.3% |
|
Has your attitude towards brushing and flossing changed? |
Yes |
211 |
78.1% |
No |
59 |
21.9% |
|
How often do you now brush your teeth? |
Once a day |
79 |
29.3% |
Twice a day |
119 |
44.1% |
|
Less than once a day |
55 |
20.4% |
|
Never |
17 |
6.3% |
|
Do you floss your teeth regularly now? |
Yes |
151 |
55.9% |
No |
119 |
44.1% |
Table 4: Engagement in Preventive Dental Care Practices.
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
How often do you now visit a dentist for check-ups or treatment? |
Regularly |
73 |
27.0% |
Occasionally |
119 |
44.1% |
|
Never |
78 |
28.9% |
|
Do you now use fluoride toothpaste? |
Yes |
199 |
73.7% |
No |
71 |
26.3% |
Table 5: Evaluation of Health Education Methods.
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
What method of learning did you find most effective in the health
education program? |
Traditional lectures |
71 |
26.3% |
Interactive activities |
101 |
37.4% |
|
Videos and visual aids |
49 |
18.1% |
|
Handouts and pamphlets |
49 |
18.1% |
|
Which of these methods helped you understand dental health better? (Check all that apply) |
Group discussions |
149 |
55.2% |
Demonstrations of techniques |
119 |
44.1% |
|
Visual aids (charts, posters) |
181 |
67.0% |
|
Lectures with real-life examples |
81 |
30.0% |
Table 6: Challenges and Barriers to Implementation.
Variable |
Response Options |
Frequency (N=270) |
Percentage |
What challenges or barriers do you think may affect the effectiveness
of the program? |
Lack of resources |
79 |
29.3% |
Inadequate time allocated |
101 |
37.4% |
|
Lack of interest from students |
61 |
22.6% |
|
Limited involvement from parents |
93 |
34.4% |
|
Cultural beliefs around dental health |
51 |
18.9% |
|
What would you recommend to improve the effectiveness of the program? |
More interactive sessions |
151 |
55.9% |
Collaboration with dental professionals |
119 |
44.1% |
|
Regular follow-up sessions |
99 |
36.7% |
|
Increased involvement of parents |
Evaluation of health
education methods
The effectiveness of the various educational methods used in the program was assessed by the students. The most preferred method was interactive activities (37.4%), followed by traditional lectures (26.3%). Videos and visual aids, along with handouts and pamphlets, were less preferred, with both at 18.1%. When asked about methods that helped them understand dental health better, most students (67.0%) highlighted the use of visual aids (charts, posters), while 55.2% found group discussions helpful. Demonstrations of brushing and flossing techniques also proved effective for 44.1% of students, indicating that practical, interactive methods had a strong impact on students’ understanding of dental hygiene (Table 5).
Challenges and barriers
to implementation
Despite the positive outcomes, several challenges and
barriers to the effectiveness of the health education program were identified.
The most common barrier, affecting 37.4% of respondents, was inadequate time
allocated for the education sessions. Lack of resources (29.3%) and limited
involvement from parents (34.4%) were also identified as significant
challenges. Interestingly, cultural beliefs around dental health were cited by
18.9% of students, suggesting that in some cases, traditional beliefs may
influence attitudes towards dental care. To address these challenges, students
recommended several improvements to the program. The most popular suggestion
was the inclusion of more interactive sessions (55.9%), followed by
collaboration with dental professionals (44.1%) and regular follow-up sessions
(36.7%). These recommendations reflect students’ preference for continuous
engagement and expert involvement to maintain the effectiveness of the health
education program (Table 6).
The demographic information of the study shows a
fairly balanced distribution across key variables. The largest group of
students was in the 15-17 age range (36%), with equal gender representation
(50% male and 50% female). This is similar to findings in other studies, which
have shown a balanced gender representation in school-based health education
programs, ensuring a broad generalizability of results [17]. In addition, the
distribution of students across different school grades (SS1, SS2, SS3) mirrors
the expectations for a representative sample from secondary schools, enhancing
the reliability of the results. Before the intervention, the students
demonstrated mixed levels of dental health knowledge, which is consistent with
previous research. A study by [18] found similar gaps in knowledge regarding
dental plaque, with nearly half of students unaware of its existence. Moreover,
67.7% of students recognized the impact of sugary foods on dental health, which
is consistent with findings from previous studies that highlighted a general
awareness of diet-related dental issues. However, only 44.8% had visited a
dentist, which aligns with findings from [19], who reported low dental
care-seeking behaviour among adolescents in Nigerian schools. The finding that
13% of students never brushed their teeth underscores the need for continuous
and effective health education interventions aimed at improving personal
hygiene practices. After the health education program, significant improvements
in dental health knowledge and attitudes were observed. A notable increase in
the percentage of students feeling more knowledgeable about dental health (67%)
mirrors the positive outcomes of similar health education interventions. For
example, a study by [20] showed that school-based dental health education
significantly improved students' knowledge about the importance of dental
hygiene and the need for regular dental check-ups. The increased frequency of
brushing twice a day (44.1%) and the rise in regular flossing (55.9%) reflect
the positive behavioral changes commonly reported in studies that evaluate the
impact of health education programs on hygiene practices [21].
These findings suggest that the program successfully
improved both cognitive and behavioral outcomes related to dental health.
Similar studies have found that dental health education can significantly
improve students' attitudes toward maintaining oral hygiene, confirming that
knowledge directly influences behavior, particularly in younger populations
[22]. The improvement in preventive practices following the program, including
an increase in the use of fluoride toothpaste (73.7%) and more frequent dentist
visits (27.0% regularly, 44.1% occasionally), aligns with findings from
research on the impact of preventive health programs. Studies have shown that
education about fluoride toothpaste and the importance of regular dental
check-ups leads to increased adherence to these practices. However, a
significant portion of students still reported not visiting the dentist
regularly (28.9%) and not using fluoride toothpaste (26.3%), which indicates
that barriers such as cost, accessibility, and awareness continue to influence
dental care-seeking behavior, as reported in previous studies [23]. The
evaluation of the educational methods used in the program reveals that students
preferred interactive activities (37.4%) and found visual aids (67.0%) most
effective in enhancing their understanding of dental health. This finding is
supported by research showing that interactive methods, including group discussions,
demonstrations, and the use of visual aids, are more effective in engaging
students and improving their retention of health-related information [24].
Studies demonstrate that such interactive and practical approaches yield better
educational outcomes compared to traditional lectures alone. The preference for
group discussions and visual aids also reflects the findings [26] who
emphasized the importance of integrating visual learning tools in school-based
health education to make abstract concepts more accessible to students. These
methods are likely to appeal more to adolescents, who tend to prefer dynamic
and participatory learning experiences over passive lectures.
Despite the positive outcomes, the study highlights
several challenges that impacted the effectiveness of the program. The most
common barrier reported was inadequate time allocated for education sessions
(37.4%), followed by lack of resources (29.3%) and limited parental involvement
(34.4%). It has been suggested that for school-based health education programs
to be successful, they need adequate resources, time, and involvement from all
stakeholders, including parents and the wider community. Furthermore, cultural
beliefs around dental health (18.9%) were identified as a significant barrier,
consistent with studies that highlight cultural influences on health
behaviours, particularly in regions with deeply ingrained traditional beliefs
[27]. To overcome these barriers, the students recommended more interactive
sessions (55.9%) and increased collaboration with dental professionals (44.1%),
which is consistent with previous studies that advocate for a
multi-disciplinary approach involving healthcare professionals to enhance the
impact of health education programs [28]. In conclusion, this study shows that
school-based health education programs can significantly improve students'
dental health knowledge, attitudes, and practices. However, challenges such as
inadequate resources, time, and cultural beliefs must be addressed to maximize
the effectiveness of such programs. Future interventions should consider the
integration of interactive, practical methods and ensure continuous engagement
with students, parents, and dental professionals to overcome barriers and
sustain the positive impact on students' oral health [29].
In conclusion, this study highlights the significant
positive impact of school-based health education programs on dental health
among secondary school students in Imo State. The results indicate that after
the implementation of the program, students demonstrated improved knowledge,
attitudes, and practices regarding dental health. There was a marked increase
in the frequency of brushing, flossing, and visiting the dentist, as well as a
greater understanding of the causes of dental decay and the importance of
preventive care. These findings emphasize the effectiveness of school-based
interventions in shaping healthier habits among adolescents, who are at a
critical age for developing lifelong health behaviours. However, despite the
improvements observed, there remain areas for further enhancement, including
addressing challenges such as limited resources, inadequate time allocation,
and cultural beliefs that influence dental health practices. These barriers
need to be addressed for the program's continued success and wider
implementation.