Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Al Salaimeh S
Keywords : Financial technology; Financial market; Structural analysis; Operations; Level; Globalization
It
is well known that the global economic crisis has produced several sub-crises
that have led to an increase in the amount harvested for the local, regional or
international markets for the sake of its consequences and at the same time
reducing future financial crises. The European Union has benefited from this
aspect, which is considered an economic and financial recurrence, due to the
use of the unified age, in addition to the presence of the Unified Bank, which
is the European Bank. As for the positive effects of such economic integration,
it is due to globalization and the digital economy. Obstacles that may occur in
front of financial transactions.
Here
comes the objective of this study, which shrouds in defining the basic
requirements in addition to the most prominent trends of economic and financial
integration of the European Union countries, within the development policies
and implementation of financial technology, where several processes are
applied, including artificial intelligence, big data, and supply chains, in
addition to crowd funding, which works on Improving dealing with customers, in
addition to managing the financial access of institutions, and do not forget
the information exchange process that takes place between financial
institutions, as this will lead to an increase in the processes of economic and
financial integration and ways of mutual cooperation between countries. The
study proved that the use of financial technology could contribute to the
processes of measures that fall within the concept of the common financial
market of the European Union countries, in order to achieve a competitive level
in this field and in the least time.
Financial
technology (Fintech), an industry consisting of companies that use technology
innovations to compete with traditional financial organizations represented by
banks and intermediaries in the financial services market. Fintech can be
attributed to the use of technology to provide financial solutions. Fintech has
emerged as a profit-driven initiative, filling untapped markets that have
become less attractive (or too costly) for financial institutions, especially
in a post-crisis environment (for example, remittances to individual countries
or regions). On the other hand, this competitive force encourages financial
innovation. Fintech can also be seen as a component of the digitization of
goods and services offered by traditional organizations, and as a response to
high compliance costs and the need to address longstanding weaknesses such as
weaknesses in data risk management. The origin of this term can be traced back
to the early 1990s. Moreover, refers to the “Financial Services Technology
Consortium”, a project initiated by Citigroup to promote technology
collaboration efforts. However, it was only after 20141 that the sector
attracted close attention from regulators, industry participants, and
consumers. The Financial Stability Board (FSB) in 2017 defined Fintech as
“technological innovation in financial services”, including in this definition
a combination of products/services (e.g. digital retail payments, digital
wallets, Fintech credit, robo-advisor3 and digital currencies) and their core
technologies.
Within
the framework of the European Economic Union (EEU), the integration processes
are affected by difficult economic conditions due to the aggravation of global
problems and the intensification of political pressure. One of the most
promising options for getting out of this situation could be to accelerate the
process of creating a common financial market, including the banking and
insurance sectors, the securities market sector, planned in accordance with the
Treaty on the Establishment of the EEU for 2025.1 In accordance with the
Treaty, within the framework of the financial integration of the EEU countries,
such areas as mutual recognition of licenses (mutual admission) are
highlighted; common payment space, cybersecurity; regulation, supervision, cooperation;
formation of a supranational body. The creation of a common space for financial
transactions and services is designed to ensure the mutual admission of
participants' financial market, protect the rights of investors and consumers
of financial services, and reduce transaction costs and financial risks.
However, political divisions and significant economic disparities hinder the
process of creating a common financial market. In this study, for the first
time, the possibilities of using financial technologies (fintech) in order to
accelerate the financial integration of the EAEU countries are considered.
fintech includes big data, artificial intelligence, machine learning,
robotization, cloud technologies and blockchain. This study focuses specifically
on the European Union (EU) as a unified institutional framework for financial
integration. The EU represents one of the most advanced models of financial
market integration supported by harmonized regulations and digital finance
strategies.
Accordingly,
the study addresses the following research question:
How
does financial technology contribute to enhancing financial integration within
the European Union?
To
answer this question, the study assumes that:
The adoption of financial technology positively influences financial integration by reducing transaction costs, improving financial accessibility, and enhancing cross-border financial interactions.
The
Aim of Study
The
aim of this study is to analyze the role of financial technology in enhancing
financial integration within the European Union by identifying key mechanisms
and measurable indicators of integration.
A
number of studies published over the past few decades have been devoted to the
problem of financial integration, which involves the creation of common
financial and credit institutions, unified centralized resource funds, an
international payment system and unified financial markets, as well as the
harmonization of legislation in the financial sector.
1. (Cooper,
1994; Edison, 2002; Gehringer, 2013).
This
study aimed to clarify the concept of financial integration with the
clarification of the impact of the efficiency of financial resources with easy
access to capital.
This
study concluded that the efficiency of the financial resources of the financial
market leads to stimulating the economic growth of companies.
2. (Edison,
2002).
This
study aimed to carry out the necessary calculations to prove the theory that
financial integration does not have a positive effect on the economic growth of
countries that enjoy a high level of banking development or financial markets
for those countries.
The
study concluded that the economic growth of countries depends entirely on
international financial integration.
3. (Klein
& Olivei, 2005).
This
study aimed to study the impact of financial integration of the European Union
countries and countries of East and Southeast Asia.
The
result of this study was that there is a significant and positive impact on the
financial market of those countries and their growth and progress.
4. (Abramova,
2021);
This
study aimed to study the most important factors affecting the European Union
integration process. Moreover, the study of the prerequisites for the
individual sectors of financial integration - monetary integration or the stock
market.
As
for the results of that study, it revealed the results of integration achieved
through mutual trade, while defining the most important tasks in the fields of
monetary and financial relations.
5. (Douglas
Arnrner, J.Barberis, R.Buckley): The evolution of fintech: A new post -crisis
paradigm? [1].
The
aim of the study was to study the impact of information technology on the
banking industry and to demonstrate the importance of information technology in
developing banking services in general, and the impact of online platforms and
payments on the function of banks. The researcher used the descriptive approach
and the analytical approach, based on a set of references and 2017 In the
2016/2016 period, the studies presented the results represented in: Information
technology plays a leading role in transforming banking, the latest embodiment
of information technology led to the “financial technology” revolution, were
banks face new competitors with new competitors. different, and that the
platforms have become the preferred customer interface, as they provide a model
A wide market through which it is possible to access many services and products
provided by various providers. Banks will become just a back office in the
field of lending.
6. (Ahmed
Hisham Al-Najjar,2021) Managing the Competitive Strategy between Financial
Technology Companies and the Islamic Banking Sector,
The
aim is to study the method of changing financial technology in the form of the
Islamic finance industry, and this is through payments and crowd funding. to a
counterpart, provided by financial technology for banking services, and the
study was conducted on a sample of Islamic banks in Indonesia in 2019/2020, and
the researcher used the descriptive and analytical approach to describe the
phenomenon and analyzed the most important points: Technology can provide an
opportunity for Islamic banks to expand their scope by compared to the
traditional bank and even the adoption of traditional banking products that are
compliant with Sharia as well Transforming some aspects of
non-Shari'a-compliant products to make them Shariah-compliant. Moreover, the
additional advantage of advanced technology is that all financial transactions
use the technology to provide transparency. Banks can provide transparency. Al
ISalamiya, clients and the state keep track of all transactions anytime we need
them financially. However, all of these technologies are in their infancy
stages and need improvements and clarification to the customer of how these
technologies work Sharia-compliant
7. (Iman
Boumod, and others,2020) financial technology innovations and their role in
developing the performance of Islamic banks,
The
aim of this study is to shed light on Islamic banks and try to keep pace with
modern technological innovations in the sector. How many of the services
provided by financial technology companies, identifying the most important
innovations and technology unions Islamic finance at the employee level of
Islamic banks, and this study was conducted on various Arab Islamic banks in
2008, and the researchers relied on the descriptive approach when addressing
the various basic concepts of the study, and the 20 20 analytical studies, with
the aim of analyzing the data, and they reached the most important results
represented in the following: The innovations of Islamic technologies
constitute a magic tool for Arab Islamic banks, helping them to enhance their
current success and at the same time imposing their presence in various
international markets, where financial technology constitutes a new means for
these banks to help them. Introducing more products and services, and financial
technology has become an urgent necessity and a strategic policy that must be
It is given its right to ensure a greater presence and wider spread of Islamic
banking systems. Innovations in financial technologies raise the fortunes of
Arab Islamic banks due to the technologies they provide.
Recent
studies emphasize the increasing role of financial technology in transforming
financial systems and accelerating financial integration. In the European
context, regulatory frameworks such as PSD2 and the Digital Finance Strategy
have facilitated fintech adoption and enhanced cross-border financial
interactions. Unlike traditional financial systems, fintech solutions
contribute to reducing information asymmetry, lowering transaction costs, and
improving access to financial services. However, the impact of these
technologies depends largely on regulatory readiness and digital infrastructure
across EU member states.
This
study adopts a qualitative analytical approach focusing on the European Union.
The methodology is based on three main components:
1. Conceptual
analysis to examine the relationship between financial technology and financial
integration.
2. Comparative
analysis of selected EU countries in terms of fintech adoption and financial
integration indicators.
3. Indicator-based
evaluation, including cross-border financial flows, digital payment usage, and
financial accessibility.
The study relies on secondary data sources such as European Commission reports and international financial databases.
Basic
requirements and problems of financial integration of the countries of the
economic and monetary union (EAEU)
Financial
integration is significant for any alliance of countries. Studies show that it
can contribute to gross domestic product (GDP) growth and positively influence
the stability of the entire economic system. At the same time, not only
possible measures were announced, but also the stages for the development of
financial integration were determined, in particular, until 2023 - to harmonize
the procedure for supervising the activities of financial market participants,
until 2025 to create a single supervisory authority in the banking sector, to
introduce mutual recognition licenses and other permits of all financial market
participants. The experience of the EU countries has shown that financial
integration is a long process, which is one of the final stages of the
intercountry integration process: from 1951 (the start date of integration
processes within the EU) to the creation of a single supranational monetary
regulatory body - the European Central Bank - and the introduction of a single
currency It's been about 48 years. On the one hand, it was easier for the EAEU
countries to implement financial integration, since all member states had
previously been members of the CIS, in which tariff customs barriers to trade
in goods were eliminated. The objective prerequisites for the financial
integration of the EAEU countries should also be taken into account, among
which the main ones are the similarity of the structures of the banking systems
and the financial market, manifested in the dominance of the banking sector in
the structure of financial markets, the competence of national central banks
(regulation, control and supervision over the activities of credit
institutions, licensing powers, not limited to banking operations) and
financial and banking legislation (transition to international financial
reporting standards (IFRS), liberalization of cross-border operations). This is
also the presence of significant cross-border financial flows in the form of
portfolio and direct investments, currency settlement relations.
On the other hand, the remaining disproportions in the development of the economy and the financial sector, along with some other contradictions between countries, did not allow significant progress in enhancing financial integration (Table 1).
First
of all, this is the absence of a single financial policy characteristic of the
EU, since the EAEU countries have uniform or differentiated norms based on
national and supranational legislation (for example, the Treaty on the EAEU,
the Concept for the Formation of a Common Financial Market, the Agreement on
the Harmonization of the Legislation of the Member States in the field of
financial market, etc.). These norms involve the redistribution of financial
flows by the EAEU states without their mobilization in the unified budget of
the alliance, the normative distribution of import, special and countervailing
duties. Some important legal acts in the financial sector, approved by the
Board of the Eurasian Economic Commission, have already been signed, others are
in the process of being agreed or finalized. It should be highlighted: - an
agreement on the admission of brokers and dealers of one EAEU member state to
the exchanges (organizers of trade) of other member states (the document is
undergoing the stage of repeated intrastate approval).
· An agreement on mutual admission to the
placement and circulation of securities on organized trading in the states
· Members of the Eurasian Economic Union
(the draft document is being finalized);
· an agreement on the implementation of
audit activities within the framework of the Eurasian Economic Union, providing
for the mutual recognition of audit reports and the possibility for audit
companies to carry out audit activities on the territory of the Union countries
(the draft agreement was signed by the heads of state at a meeting of the
Supreme Eurasian Economic Council in December 2021);
· an agreement on coordinated approaches to
the regulation of foreign exchange relations and the adoption of liberalization
measures, granting the right to open accounts (deposits) in foreign currency on
the territory of the state.
· An agreement on the procedure for
exchanging information included in credit histories within the framework of the
Eurasian Economic Union (the agreements were signed in December 2021)11;
· Roadmap for the formation of a single
exchange space of the Eurasian Economic Union (approved by the Board of the
Eurasian Economic Commission in November 2020) (Gehringer A. Growth, 2013).
at
the same time, the coordination and adoption of such important decisions as the
introduction of a standardized license, the creation of a supranational body
for the regulation of financial markets, mutual admission to the placement and
circulation of securities on organized trading in the member states, mutual
recognition of national rating agencies, etc., is scheduled for the period
until the end of 2025. The lack of close interaction between national financial
markets and sufficiently deep economic integration of the EAEU countries does
not allow realizing the positive impact of financial integration on the
economies of the countries of the alliance. For the development of financial
integration, the achievement of monetary integration plays an important role.
It was this approach that was implemented in the EU, when, against the
background of the introduction of a single currency, countries managed to
eliminate currency risks within the alliance and stabilize inflation at a low
level. The issue of creating a single currency, for which the names
"Evraz" or "Altyn" were proposed, was initially present in
the draft declaration on the EAEU, but because of its discussion, the negative
position of Hungaria was taken into account and, as a result, this item was not
included in the final document.
Another
problematic area is the functioning of the common capital market, which is
complicated by both the significant predominance of Serbian investments and the
instability of aggregate investment flows (they have decreased by more than 2.2
times over the past three years). To solve the identified problems, in October
2019, the Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC) approved the Concept for the
formation of a common financial market of the EAEU, the implementation of which
should be ensured by banking regulators. After a three-year discussion, in
2020, an Agreement was signed on the harmonization of legislation in the
financial sector, which spelled out the stages for the convergence of the norms
and requirements of national legislation.
The
development of financial technologies and the possibility of their use to
enhance financial integration
Differences
in macroeconomic indicators remain in the EAEU countries both in terms of
living standards and the ratio of public debt to GDP. These differences create
additional difficulties for the Union in seeking to further integrate
institutions and markets. Moreover, in 2020-2021. There was a significant
decrease in the level of investment compared to 2019, which indicates the need
for restoration procedures and support from regulators. Of course, this process
is complicated by both economic and political factors. Economic factors include
the instability of economies and the different directions of their
transformations, the insufficient level of development of financial systems, as
well as the presence of differences and barriers in financial markets. The
ambiguity of the positions of regulators and their unwillingness to take into
account the new opportunities of blockchain, artificial intelligence,
cryptocurrencies and big data also remain. Thus, in Poland, Hungary and Romania
the effectiveness of their use was noted for optimizing the VAT refund process
and working with clients of financial institutions, when evaluating borrowers,
managing the assets of financial institutions, in insurance, for exchanging
information (in these countries, regulations have been adopted in the field of
the digital economy). The introduction of fintech, which is already being used
in Poland and Hungary and covers all areas identified by the EEC as
prerequisites for creating a common financial market:
· blockchain - interbank settlements instead
of SWIFT and settlements under a letter of credit, as well as secured lending,
customer identification;
· big data and digital currencies — access
for brokers and dealers to the markets of the EAEU countries, creation of a
single credit platform, exchange of information as part of credit histories,
the possibility of obtaining loans throughout the alliance;
· crowd funding — the development of the
securities market and the implementation of public investments in the markets
of other countries via the Internet;
· Digital currency - the development of
cashless payments in the form of remote payments and online payments, as well
as offline in the absence of access to the Internet.
Moreover,
in Hungary legal framework for operations with crypto-currencies is allowed and
formed. At the same time, in Bulgaria in the absence of a legal framework, some
startups work in the field of cryptocurrencies, and in the Poland, the
possibilities of their implementation are still being studied.
The
banking regulator of Hungary announced that it will sum up the results of
testing the digital tinge in July 2022, while the regulators of other EAEU
countries are only studying the possibility of introducing a digital currency.
The modern financial sector, which has a high integration potential, is
developing against the backdrop of accelerating digitalization, which is
fundamentally changing traditional economic models. Fintech, by modifying
traditional financial markets, provides significant opportunities to expand
access to financial services. Technology and new data sources make it easier,
cheaper and faster to access economic processes not only in advanced market
economies but also in developing countries. Fintech allows to mitigate the
possible negative consequences of EU financial integration (in addition to the
loss of macroeconomic stability), manifested in the following: difficulties in
accessing less developed countries to sources of financing, disproportionate
internal distribution of financial flows, high probability of changes in
capital flows, as well as risks of penetration of foreign banks. In addition,
fintech is driving the emergence of new ways of financing and increasing the
availability of financial services [2]. One such alternative financing method
is crowdfunding, which is carried out through Internet platforms or social
networks and is available to individuals who, due to a lack of credit history
or credit collateral, are not interested in lending to banks, or who are unable
to obtain financing on commercial terms. On the basis of crowdfunding, it is
possible to provide financial support not only to commercial projects, but also
to social enterprises, projects in the field of healthcare, education, culture,
art, which have their own “stakeholders”.
In
particular, it seems expedient to create a common lending platform that allows,
through the exchange of information from credit histories, to attract financing
on the territory of any country of the alliance. A “pilot” project of such a
platform could be a crowdfunding platform of the EAEU countries, which will
provide for three groups of projects - based on lending, donations and rewards.
Examination (trustworthiness assessment) of proposed projects because of
remuneration can be carried out by national entrepreneurship support funds, and
the creditworthiness of borrowers of credit projects can be assessed by
national banks that provide information to the Advisory Committee on Financial
Markets of the EEC. The functioning of such a platform will make it possible to
direct resources precisely to those market segments that are not yet attractive
for traditional financing, but which are of significant socio-economic
importance for the EAEU. Legal entities that are not financial institutions and
individuals, being confident in the safety of their investments, will have the
opportunity to financially participate in the implementation of the project
they are interested in in any country of the Union. The digitalization of
certain areas of business activity in the EAEU countries makes it possible to
ensure the transparency of the implementation of financial integration
projects, and, consequently, their greater attractiveness, which can only be
implemented in conditions of full trust and legal registration of the common
goals and interests of investment participants. The use of more “advanced”
experience in terms of introducing FinTech and ensuring its security in Belarus
and Russia will allow Hungaria, Poland and the Bulgaria Republic to accelerate
the process of introducing new innovative tools and services, as well as avoid
mistakes and problems before only in terms of the quality of regulation of
information and communication services and the Internet, low qualification of
personnel [3] (Table 2).
Based
on a study conducted by the Ernst & Young consulting company, whose annual
report provides an analysis of the situation in the global fintech space, it
should be recognized that its development is impossible without the active
support of the governments and financial regulatory authorities of the EAEU
countries, which are pursuing a policy of expanding access to financial
services and creating for this legal basis. That is why it is important to
accelerate the process of creating a supranational body, as well as to
intensify the exchange of information about innovations in the field of fintech
in the market of each country of the union, as well as problems and trends in
the development of the regulatory mechanism. To enhance financial integration,
the EAEU countries need to more quickly create conditions for the introduction
of new technologies, common financial platforms and digital currency, since in
the absence of them, potential investors and investment recipients will be
forced to use these tools in other jurisdictions. As rightly noted in the
report of the Eurasian Development Bank, the integration of financial
infrastructure can reduce costs, improve risk management, and also contribute
to the growth of trade volumes and the expansion of regional capital markets.
The EAEU countries have an understanding of the need to intensify digital
transformation at the supranational level. In particular, K.A. Minasyan,
Minister for Internal Markets, Informatization and Information and
Communication Technologies of the Eurasian Economic Commission, noted that
digital transformation is becoming the most important factor in competitiveness
and recognized the importance of “forming a modern Eurasian financial
infrastructure, Eurasian digital and financial payment platforms, and digital
financial instruments”. Positive consequences may become even more pronounced
after the completion of the testing period of the digital Euro, which allows
not only to create a platform for the formation of an infrastructure for the electronic
circulation of financial instruments of the EAEU countries, but also to promote
the introduction of blockchain technologies to involve financial intermediaries
of all member countries of the union. The creation of the FinTech Association
of the EAEU countries, which includes investors, banking institutions, venture
companies, start-ups, entrepreneurs, politicians, experts, representatives of
ICT companies, etc., can also provide great assistance in deepening financial
integration.
This
study is based on transaction cost theory and financial integration theory.
Financial technology reduces transaction costs and enhances efficiency, while
financial integration theory explains how capital mobility and regulatory
harmonization improve market performance. In addition, network externalities
theory highlights the increasing value of digital financial platforms as more
users participate in the system.
During
the study, the following work was carried out
Through
the foregoing, we see that the basic requirements for the most prominent
economic and financial integration trends of the European Union countries have
been identified and defined, in addition to giving a detailed explanation of
the impact of financial technology on the common financial market. The results
indicate that financial technology plays a significant role in enhancing
financial integration within the European Union. The analysis shows that
fintech applications contribute to improving access to financial services and
facilitating cross-border financial transactions. Furthermore, countries with
higher levels of fintech adoption tend to demonstrate stronger financial
integration indicators, particularly in digital payments and financial accessibility.
The
findings suggest that while financial technology enhances integration, its
impact varies across EU countries due to differences in regulatory frameworks
and digital infrastructure.
Additionally,
the rapid growth of fintech introduces challenges such as cybersecurity risks
and regulatory complexity, which require coordinated policy responses at the
European level [4-15].
Scientific
addition
The
scientific addition of this study lies in its introducing and explaining the
concept of financial technology while specifying the impact of this technology
on the common financial market (the European Union market as an example).
In
recent years, political and economic problems and contradictions have persisted
in the integration of the EU countries; tension periodically arises in
bilateral relations between the countries of the alliance. There are also new
risks associated with the closure of state borders and a reduction in mutual
trade due to the COVID-19 pandemic. As a result, the threat of the global
financial crisis, the volatility of national currencies and the growth of
inflationary pressure is increasing, which leads to a slowdown in the process
of financial integration. In addition, the model of financial integration,
recognized as successfully implemented in the EU, does not suit the EU
countries that are not ready to limit national sovereignty in the political and
economic spheres in order to intensify integration processes in all segments of
the economy. The slow progress of work on harmonization of legislation in the
financial sector necessitates the development of financial mechanisms and
instruments capable of activating entrepreneurial activity, expanding sources
of financing for economic entities and minimizing financial risks. Moreover,
this can be of great help to the introduction of financial technologies, which
not only modify traditional financial markets, but also offer additional
opportunities for the development of alternative financing. However, in order
to unleash the full potential of new investment areas and opportunities, the EU
countries need to join forces and create a strong mechanism and a flexible system
of relationships between fintech organizations, platforms and businesses. This
study confirms that financial technology is a key driver of financial
integration within the European Union. However, achieving full integration
requires harmonized regulatory frameworks and continuous technological
development.