Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Aguirrechu CI, Oca MD, Yera EDC, Rojas SI, Lopez AC, Garcia AG, Matos E, Rodriguez VLM, Perez DRM and Carvajal M
Keywords : Renal carcinoma; Clear cells; Nephrectomy; Predictor
Renal cell carcinoma
(RCC) represents 4% of total cases of neoplasms globally and 90% of renal
tumors, with a higher frequency of incidence between the fifth and seventh
decades of life. The incidence varies between different regions and is more
frequent in Scandinavia and North America and infrequent in Africa [1].
RCC affects more than 400,000 people annually
worldwide, resulting in 175, 098 deaths each year. Incidental diagnosis by
images is frequent in asymptomatic patients, most with localized tumors smaller
than 4 cm (50% to 70% of RCC) [1,2]. It is more common in terms of sex in the
risk of RCC for men of 1:69 and women of 1: 116 [2]. It is a predominant tumor
in old age, although the number of new cases has a tendency to increase in young
patients [3]. At the time of the diagnosis, approximately 40% of patients have
an already disseminated regional or distant pathology. The locations and
frequency of invasion are as follows: lung (multiple nodules) (67-76%), lymph
nodes (40-66%), bone (lytic lesions, rarely blastic) (42%), liver (41%),
contralateral kidney (23%), ipsilateral adrenal (17%), opposite adrenal (11%),
brain (11%) [3,4]. The main therapeutic option in the treatment of localized
disease has been open radical nephrectomy, now the use of partial nephrectomy
begins to be more frequent by minimal access techniques. The progress of
medical technology in the last decade has led to the discovery of genetic bases
and molecular pathways, which has enabled the implementation of novel therapies
aimed at these discoveries. The identification of prognostic factors help to
propose the most appropriate therapeutic strategy, to direct future treatments
and develop specific follow-up schemes. They are divided into
anatomy-pathological elements (tumour size, vascular invasion, Fuhrman’s
degree, adrenal invasion, tumor necrosis, lymphadenopathy, metastases);
clinical (Karnofsky, systemic symptoms), laboratory (serum calcium, haemoglobin
and LDH values); histological (histological subtype, presence of sarcomatoid
pattern) and molecular (HIF, PTEN, p53, ki-67) [5]. RCC, although it is not one
of adult’s malignant tumors with the highest incidence rate, it constitutes a
real challenge for its diagnosis and treatment. In most cases, the diagnosis is
incidental and radical surgery is the strongest basis for treatment, multiple
drugs have been added to the therapeutic drugs list approved by the FDA in
recent years with a high cost and little benefit [6]. There are not enough
related reports in our country on the characterization of renal cell tumors, so
its study is important for a future identification of related prognostic
factors and identified risk groups. In order to identify the behaviour of the
RCC and the prognostic elements associated with its evolution, the present
study was carried out to characterize the clinical-epidemiological behaviour in
patients operated in the institution according with their prognostic factors.
We conducted an
observational, retrospective, and longitudinal-cut study of patients with a
diagnosis of RCC, with surgical and the following, was carried out at the
¨Hermanos Ameijeiras” hospital in the period from January 2006 to December
2015. From the universe of Kidneys Tumors hospital was included a sample of 336
patients who received kidney tumours surgery and with availability of data in
primary sources of hospital records. Statistical analysis. We used descriptive
statistics to analyze our data set. Qualitative variables were summarized
through arithmetic means, standard deviation, median, interquartile range and
minimum and maximum values. For the qualitative variables, absolute frequencies
and percentages were calculated. A Cox regression model was adjusted to study
the influence of demographic, anatomical, clinical-histological and laboratory
variables on survival, with the consequent estimation of the risk ratios with
their 95% confidence interval. The study was conducted in accordance with the provisions
of the Helsinki Declaration of the World Medical Association, taking into
account the latest update at the 64th General Assembly in Fortaleza, Brazil,
October 2013, on research in human beings. The privacy, reliability and
integrity of the data obtained from the patients was respected with the
responsibility and obligation of not disclosing their identity.
Regarding the demographic characteristics of the patients, more than 65% were male and with white skin color (77.1%). The median age was 57.8 years, with 65% of patients concentrated in the range between 50 and 69 years of age. Only significant is the impact on the median survival in terms of sex with p = 0.023 95% CI (median 9 years female vs. 7.4 years in male) (Figures 1 and 2).
Figure 1: Overall Survival (OS) estimation (years) according to risk factors identified in patients with renal cell carcinoma.
Figure 2: Overall Survival (Kaplan-Meier) according to correlational Risk Group 1.
The most frequent comorbidities were Arterial Hypertension (59.2%) and Diabetes Mellitus (36.0%), 14.9% of the patients (n=50) did not report any comorbidity. Only five patients were able to document Chronic Renal Failure associated with the diagnosis. Most of the patients were diagnosed without referred symptoms (64%), in correspondence to general average check-up or by alteration of some laboratory parameter. The symptoms and signs present had a similar distribution in hematuria (12.2%), low back pain (13.1%) and palpable tumor mass (10.7%) without significant predominance of one or the other and with a low frequency in the sample. Majority of the histological samples analyzed corresponded to classical RCC (72.9%), and 11.9% to the papillary variant type I. Only in six samples was the sarcomatoid and mixed or tubular pattern identified, chromophobic pattern was confirmed in 23 biopsy samples. Majority corresponded to nuclear Grade II (59.5%), Grade III (21.7%), according to the ISUP Classification (International Society of Urological Pathology) (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Overall Survival (Kaplan-Meier) according to correlational Risk Group 2.
The tumors characterized by less than 7 cm of diameter (79.2%), vascular permeation in 14.6%, capsular infiltration in 20.8% and the presence of thrombi in the renal vein only in 2.4% of them. Clinical Stage I was represented by the 70.2%, whereas only 3% turned into Stage IV. There was a similar frequency of patients classified as Stage II and III (49 and 41 respectively). Clinical stage was one of the significant variables to survival analyze with p=0.000 between I and II stage vs. III (84,5-85,9 years vs. 58,9 years) and tumour size showed statistical difference (p=0,008 per ? 7 vs. 7-10 cm of diameter and p=0,018 per ? 7 vs. > 10 cm of diameter). Regarding the laboratory parameters evaluated during the diagnosis, the average velocity erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) was 68 mm/h (30-190); by categorizing this variable into intermediate (20.1-50 mm/h) and very high (> 50 mm/h) values, which represented 76.5% of the case subjects. The median haemoglobin value was 11 mg/dL (81% of patients were diagnosed with anaemia). Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) values patients debuted with values above the normal upper limit (140 to 570 mg/dL). In most cases, surgery could be performed (96.4%). In the small remaining group, only incisional renal biopsy was performed; 60.8% were nephrectomy (radical and partial) and in the remaining 38.3% only lumpectomy. The nephrectomy performed had a distribution of between the radical and partial nephrectomies (50.9 vs. 9, 8% respectively). Only 3% of cases received systemic treatment with adjuvant (with recombinant interferon ? 2r). A global survival analysis of the patients performed according to clinical and pathological variables, laboratory testing and treatment received. Death events occurred for 56 (16.7%). The overall survival of the 336 cases was between 8 and 9 years (95% CI: 8.1 - 8.9). The 5-year overall survival rate was 79.9%. To study the influence of baseline variables, both clinical and histological, a Cox model was adjusted, where a statistically significant dependence for survival was confirmed according to the presence of capsular infiltration and renal vein thrombi in addition to the nuclear grade. The risk of dying in those with capsular infiltration is 2.6 times higher; as well as in those who have thrombi in the renal vein (3.7 times higher), nuclear grade I and II it is significantly lower (half and a third) than those who have grade III and males present a one year lower survival than females. Although, from the multivariate review no other significant associations regarding survival were detected, some cases to collinearity among vascular permeation, capsule infiltration and presence of thrombi. Statistically significant influences in gender, tumour size, clinical stage, vascular permeation, anaemia, LDH greater than 400 mg/dL were detected. Two individual risk scenarios were estimated based on the following variables:
Risk 1:
Presence of Anaemia, high DHL values (? 400 mg / dL) and ESR (intermediate or
high range)
Risk 2: Presence of Anaemia, elevated DHL values (? 400 mg/) and ESR (intermediate or high range) plus presence of thrombi in renal vein
Overall, a maximum incidence
of presentation between 60 and 70 years old was described. A study with 112
patients with RCC with a similar frequency (33.9%) in the 50-59 age group.
Also, although they did not sub classify the sample in the same age range,
reported a similar frequency of individuals (38.6%) between the ages of 50 and
64 [8,9].
In the Cuban context, a higher frequency of the male gender has been reported, for a male: female ratio of 1.8: 1. These results are very close to those found in this work where male sex prevailed in a 2: 1 ratio and totally coincident. However, a slightly higher ratio in favour of men (2,5:1) [8-10]. The absence of symptoms are in correspondence with the evolution of imaging techniques (incidentally in about 40-50% of cases). Due to the wide availability of imaging techniques such as ultrasound, computed tomography and nuclear magnetic resonance, the number of incidentally diagnosed renal tumors has increased in early organ-confined stages, (I and II), which allows more conservative treatments and with good survival results [11]. On the other hand, the absence of symptoms may also be influenced by the fact that most tumors measured less than 7 cm of diameter, which corresponds to a lower clinical stage of the disease. Local invasion of the tumor with infiltration of the renal capsule occurs in 20% of patients according to several studies, as in the present study [13] (Tables 1-3).
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of patients.
Basal Characteristic |
Frequency |
% | |
N |
336 |
100 | |
Gender |
Masculine |
228 |
67,9 |
Female |
108 |
32,1 | |
Skin color |
White |
259 |
77,1 |
Black |
32 |
9,5 | |
Mixed |
45 |
13,4 | |
Age |
Median ± DS |
57,8 ± 10,6 | |
Mean (minim; maxim) |
58,0 (20; 79) | ||
|
13 |
3,9 | |
|
59 |
17,6 | |
|
110 |
32,7 | |
|
109 |
32,4 | |
|
45 |
13,4 |
Table 2: Pathological tumors characteristics.
Anatomy-pathological
characterizations |
Frequency |
% | |
N |
336 |
100,0 | |
Tumor size |
? 7 cm |
266 |
79,2 |
7 - 10 cm |
47 |
14,0 | |
> 10 cm |
23 |
6,8 | |
Vascular-lymphatic
Permeation |
yes |
49 |
14,6 |
No |
279 |
83,0 | |
No specific |
8 |
2,4 | |
Capsular Infiltration |
yes |
70 |
20,8 |
No |
257 |
76,5 | |
No specific |
9 |
2,7 | |
Renal vein thrombus |
Si |
8 |
2,4 |
No |
319 |
94,9 | |
No specific |
9 |
2,7 | |
Clinical stage i |
I |
236 |
70,2 |
II |
49 |
14,6 | |
III |
41 |
12,2 | |
IV |
10 |
3,0 | |
i TNM
classifications. Renal Cell Carcinoma. American Joint Cancer Committee (AJCC)
(7maed., 2010) |
The low frequency of thrombi in renal vein observed may be due to the low frequency of Stage IV patients with metastases which has been reported on between 4% and 10% of cases; this effect is more frequently (up to 25%) in patients with metastatic renal carcinoma (13,14). A quarter of the patients presented preoperative anaemia, totally contrary to what was observed in this investigation, where more than three quarters of the sample presented anaemia (haemoglobin <10mg/dl) even when they did not refer related symptoms such as paleness or bleeding at that same frequency. Surgery that prevailed in the case series coincides with what was notified by other authors and with the current recommendation for this entity (IA). In the study 81.2% of the patients underwent radical nephrectomy, although this the frequency was slightly higher than that observed in the present work. Because most patients are diagnosed when the tumor is still relatively localized and is susceptible to surgery, approximately 73% of all patients with RCC survive for 5 years [11].
Table 3: Laboratory test baseline values.
Baselines
values |
Descriptive | ||
N |
=336 | ||
Erythrocyte
sedimentations rate, ESR, (mm/h) |
Median ± DS |
68,9 ± 20,2 | |
Mean ± RI |
68,0 ± 27,0 | ||
(minim; maxim) |
(30; 190) | ||
20,1- 50 |
79 |
23,5% | |
> 50 |
257 |
76,5% | |
Hemoglobin (mg/dL) |
Median ± DS |
10,3 ± 1,9 | |
Mean ± RI |
11,0 ± 3,0 | ||
(Minim; maxim) |
(6; 14) | ||
Anemia (Hb < 10,0 mg/dL) |
Yes |
272 |
81,0% |
No |
64 |
19,0% | |
HLD (mg/dL)
|
Median ± DS |
299,7 ± 81,9 | |
Mean ± RI |
280,0 ± 110,0 | ||
(Minim; Maxim) |
(140; 570) | ||
<=400 |
302 |
89,9% | |
>400 |
34 |
10,1% |
The precise
determination of prognostic factors is an essential to evaluate patients with
RCC, for the determination of adjuvant treatments and prediction of the
evolution of the disease. In the present study, a direct influence of the male
sex, tumor size > 7cm of diameter), clinical Stage III-IV, vascular and/or
lymphatic permeation, anaemia and DHL> 400 mg / dL was observed in the
outcome of the patients (lower survival). The risk of individual stratification
established from laboratory tests is an independent and significant predictor
of overall survival.
The authors declare the
non-existence of a conflict of interest, and strict compliance with the
confidentiality of the data collected.