Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Drali O, Arab M, Lamdjadani N, Delacourt C and Hadchouel
Keywords : Vitamin D; Atopic manifestations; Children; Algeria
Introduction:
Known
since antiquity for its antirachitic action, vitamin D has benefited a
considerable revival of interest over the past twenty years in research topics.
It is considered to be a physiological regulator of the proliferation and
differentiation of many cell types and as a modulator of the body's immune
defenses. Vitamin D seems to play a role in intrauterine and postnatal lung
development, and several studies suggest its involvement in the development of
asthma and allergies. The objective of this study was to find out any
association between the incidence of wheezy symptoms and atopic manifestations,
and insufficient vitamin D status in a population of young Algerian children.
It was a retrospective study by phone questionnaire. As part of a first work,
the objective of which was to make an inventory of vitamin D status in young
Algerian children, a measurement of total 25 OHD (D2 + D3) was carried out in
397 children aged 9 to 24 months living in an urban environment (Algiers)
between 2014 and 2016. For the present project, all the parents of these
children were contacted by phone to answer a questionnaire. A statistical
analysis was applied to assess the relationship between the vitamin D status of
the child aged from 9 to 24 months and the incidence of the various
pathological manifestations 2 years later.
Results:
A 397 children from the initial study were eligible for our study, 348 children
collected. 29.9% of children had a vitamin D deficiency (25 OHD?20 ng / ml) and
15.5% had a vitamin D severe deficiency (25 OHD?10 ng / ml). The optimal
vitamin D level (25 OHD? 30 ng / ml) was only reached in 28.7% of children. The
incidence of asthma was significantly higher in children with vitamin D
deficiency compared to those without vitamin D deficiency (p = 0.001). The mean
vitamin D concentration was significantly lower in children with asthma than in
children without asthma (p = 0.0001). Vitamin D levels were also associated to
other atopic manifestations (rhinitis, food allergy and atopic dermatitis).
Conclusion:
Confirmation of an impact of vitamin D deficiency in the first 2 years of life
on the appearance of atopic manifestations in young children would be of major
interest for the update of the Algerian national recommendations concerning
supplementation in vitamin D.
Allergic (atopic) diseases result from an interaction
between individual genetic susceptibility and exposure to environmental
factors. The prenatal and early postnatal periods of life have been identified
as "windows of opportunity" during which immune responses can be
permanently programmed. Besides a clear genetic basis in allergic diseases,
environmental factors, including vitamin D status, can exert an important
influence on the development of allergies and therefore represent an
opportunity to prevent or delay the onset of these pathologies.
Known since antiquity, for its antirachitic action,
vitamin D has benefited from a considerable revival of interest over the past
twenty years in research topics and the scientific literature is enriched every
day with new data concerning this topic. Studies on its structure and that of
its receptor, its metabolism, its mechanisms and its ubiquitous field of action
have gradually shifted this compound from the status of vitamin to that of
hormone. It is also considered to be a physiological regulator of the
proliferation and differentiation of many cell types and as a modulator of the
body's immune defenses. Vitamin D appears to play a role in intrauterine and
postnatal lung development, and several studies suggest its involvement in the
development of asthma and allergies [1,2].
Find out any association between the incidence of
atopic manifestations and vitamin D deficient status in a population of young
Algerian children.
This is a retrospective study undertaken by phone
questionnaire. An inventory of vitamin D status in young Algerian children by
measuring total 25 OHD (D2 + D3) was carried out in 397 children from nine (9)
to 24 months old living in an urban environment (Algiers) between 2014 and
2016. PTH, calcemia, phosphoremia, albuminemia and creatinemia were also
measured. For this study, part of this population was included. The sample was
taken according to a random survey by simple lot drawing by numbering (statistical
method validated by the WHO). All regulatory approvals were obtained (Ministry
of Health, Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research and the
National Statistics Office).
We have included children:
Not receiving any treatment, which could interfere with the metabolism of vitamin D or the phosphocalcic metabolism: anticonvulsants, steroids, and rifampicin.
Having a vitamin D dosage available due to their participation in the princeps study.
The following cases were excluded from the study:
· Children born or
consulting at the above-mentioned structures but not from the commune of
Hussein Dey.
· Children with an incomplete national prevention scheme (a single intake of vitamin D).
Preparation of the phone questionnaire (validated by
the Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific
Research and the National Statistics Office). A phone questionnaire was
established to respond to the objective of the study.
This questionnaire was divided into several parts:
General
data
Date of birth, sex, previous vitamin D supplementation.
Collection
of clinical manifestations
Explanations to the objectives and the modalities of the survey were provided to parents by phone. After obtaining the parents 'informed consent, a schedule for answering the questionnaire was set so as not to disrupt the parents' daily activity. During the study, the total 25-OHD was assayed on serum after centrifugation by the VIDAS BioMérieux analyzer, which allows the immuno-enzymatic determination of 25OHD by the ELFA technique (Enzyme Linked Fluorecent Assay) by combining an immunoenzymatic phase by competition to a final fluorescence detection. This technique measures the two forms 25 OH D3 and 25OH D2 expressed in ng/ml in accordance with international recommendations. The vitamin D standards used for the evaluation of our results are those accepted by the majority of authors: Vitamin D deficiency (25 OHD?20 ng / ml), vitamin D severe deficiency (25 OHD?10 ng / ml). The optimal vitamin D level (25 OHD? 30 ng / ml).
Statistical
analyses
Quantitative variables were expressed as means with
their standard deviation. The comparison of the quantitative variables between
the different groups was carried out by the Student's t-test; the homogeneity
of the variances was verified through the Levene test. Qualitative variables
were expressed in terms of frequency and percentage. The comparison of the
distributions of the qualitative variables between the different groups was
achieved by the Chi-square test. Fisher's exact test was used when the Chi-square
test was not feasible (theoretical or calculated numbers < 5).The results
were considered significant at the 5% level. The analyses were carried out with
SPSS 22 software.
Description
of the population
A 397 children from the initial study were eligible for our study, 348 children collected. 8.8% were lost to follow-up. We recruited the children during the 4 seasons in order to appreciate the seasonal variation of the vitamin D concentration. The distribution of the sample was homogeneous between the four seasons (p = 0.08).The average age of the children in our series was 5 years ± 0.74 with a sex ratio of 1.01 (175 boys / 173 girls). Calcemia, phosphoremia, albuminemia and the assessment of kidney function showed no abnormalities. The average serum total vitamin D concentration in our series was 23.3 ± 12.1 ng / ml, significantly lower than the current recommendations for benefiting from the extra skeletal effects of vitamin D (25 OHD> 30 ng / ml) with a mean PTH level at 30.3 ± 13.2 pg / ml(normal). Results of serum levels of total 25 OHD are shown in (Table 1).
Table 1: Blood vitamin D level according to the season.
Season
|
Spring |
Summer |
Autumn |
Winter |
P |
Mean ± SD (ng/ml) |
24,3 ± 11,5 |
30,3 ± 11,6 |
20,6 ± 11,3 |
15,9 ± 8,7 |
0.0001 |
Table 2: Prevalence of vitamin D status according to the various thresholds.
Vitamin
D level |
N
|
Frequency
(%) |
Severe deficit |
54 |
15,5 |
Deficit |
104 |
29,9 |
Insufficiency |
90 |
25,9 |
Optimal |
100 |
28,7 |
Table 3: Correlation between the vitamin D levels and the incidence of the allergic rhinitis.
Allergic rhinitis |
Total |
P | |||
NO |
YES |
| |||
Number Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency |
338 |
10 |
348 |
| |
46,4%
|
100% |
|
0,001 | ||
|
|
|
| ||
Vitamin D concentration(ng/ml) |
23,6 ± 12 |
10,02 ± 2,8 |
|
0,001 |
Table 4: Correlation between of vitamin D level and the incidence of the atopic dermatitis.
Atopic dermatitis |
Total |
P | |||
NO |
YES |
| |||
Number
Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency
|
341 |
7 |
348 |
| |
46,9%
|
100% |
|
0,005 | ||
|
|
|
| ||
Vitamin D concentration(ng/ml) |
23,5 ± 12 |
21,01 ± 2,7 |
|
0,003 |
Table 5: Correlation between vitamin D plasma levels and the incidence of the food allergy.
Food allergy |
Total |
P |
||
NO |
YES |
|
||
Number Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency |
343 |
5 |
348 |
|
47,2%
|
100% |
|
0,02 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vitamin D concentration(ng/ml) |
23,4 ± 12,1 |
13,4 ± 4,1 |
|
0,05 |
Table 6: Correlation between the vitamin D level and the occurrence of asthma.
Asthma |
Total |
P |
||
NO |
YES |
|
||
Number Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency
|
312 |
36 |
348 |
|
43,3%
|
88,9% |
|
0,001 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vitamin D concentration(ng/ml) |
24,3 ± 12 |
14,4 ± 7 |
|
0,0001 |
The highest vitamin D concentrations were found in summer with an average concentration of 30.3 ± 11.6 ng / ml compared to winter when the average concentration was 15.9 ± 8.7 ng / ml, this difference was highly significant (p = 0.0001). 29.9% of children had a vitamin D deficiency (25 OHD?20 ng / ml) and 15.5% had a vitamin D severe deficiency (25 OHD?10 ng / ml). The optimal vitamin D level (25 OHD? 30 ng / ml) was only reached in 28.7% of children 17% of children had atopic manifestations. Ten children had allergic rhinitis. Seven children suffered from atopic dermatitis. Food allergies were reported in 5 children, allergy to cow's milk protein in 4 children, 1 child had an allergy to strawberries. The diagnosis of asthma was reported in 36 children (Table 2).
Relationship
between vitamin D concentrations in young children and the incidence of atopic
manifestations
All patients with allergic rhinitis were deficient in
vitamin D. The mean vitamin D concentration was lower in children with allergic
rhinitis compared to children who did not have allergic rhinitis (p = 0.001)
(Table 3). Patients with atopic dermatitis were deficient in vitamin D. The
mean vitamin D concentration was lower in children with atopic dermatitis
compared to children who did not have atopic dermatitis (p = 0.003) (Table 4).
Patients with a food allergy were deficient in vitamin D. The concentration of
vitamin D was lower in children with a food allergy compared to children who
did not have food allergy allergic rhinitis insignificantly (p = 0, 05) (Table
5). The incidence of asthma was significantly higher in children with vitamin D
deficiency compared to those without vitamin D deficiency (p = 0.001). The mean
vitamin D concentration was significantly lower in children with asthma than in
children without asthma (p = 0.0001) (Table 6).
The incidence of atopic manifestations varies
significantly depending on the vitamin D status in our population of younger
Algerian children. Average vitamin D concentrations were lower in children who
developed these disorders. As a result, vitamin D deficiency would expose to
the risk of the occurrence of allergic manifestations in our population
confirming the results of the majority of studies published on this topic. Our
comments will cover several aspects. We will first make a critical analysis of
the approach adopted and the problems encountered during the investigation. We
will compare our results with the data in the literature in second step by
discussing them. Our study presents some positive points. The sample size is
quite large and both sexes were well represented. Vitamin D plasma
concentrations were assessed during the 4 seasons demonstrating the effect of
seasonality on the variation in the level of 25 OHD. The 25 OHD assay technique
has been validated by several expert reports and allows the determination of
the two forms of vitamin D used for all patients. The study suffer some
weaknesses and limitations. This survey made by a questionnaire suffers from
its declarative and therefore subjective character. Thus, the low incidence of
food allergies in our study could be explained by this declarative nature and
questioning only the parents. The study is limited to the commune of Hussein
Dey alone. There is no standard definition of vitamin D status. Currently, many
experts support a 25 OHD threshold greater than 30 ng / ml to consider a normal
level [3]. This threshold is justified by the wish to allow the subjects to
benefit from the effect of vitamin D on the bone but also on other pathologies
while others fix the threshold of 20 ng / ml as minimum threshold in order to
optimize calcium absorption [4]. Several pediatric consensus define in children
the deficit at the threshold of 20 ng / ml and the vitamin D deficiency at the
threshold of 10 ng / ml [5]. The diversity of the populations studied, in
particular in terms of latitude, geographic origin or age, the variability of
the assay techniques and the lack of real consensus on the reference thresholds
for defining the deficit makes international comparisons difficult. However,
there is an increase in the vitamin D deficit in all latitudes and all
continents [6,7]. Several studies dedicated to the relationship between vitamin
D, asthma and allergies have increased significantly. Experimental evidence in
rats shows that fetal type II alveolar epithelial cells express vitamin D
receptor (VDR), suggesting that lung maturation is sensitive to exposure to
vitamin D [8,9]. In humans, Kho et al. examined gene expression profiles during
human fetal lung development and identified a number of genes associated with
the vitamin D signaling pathway whose expression was developmentally regulated
[10]. Although the exact role of these vitamin D-linked genes in fetal lung
development remains to be fully explored, several genes (LAMP3 PIP5K1B, SCRAB2
and TXNIP) have also been found to be significantly overexpressed in cells
derived from asthmatic children, suggesting thus a link between the vitamin D
pathway genes, fetal development and asthma, [11]. Zosky studied the effects of
vitamin D deficiency in a mouse model. The offspring of vitamin D deficient
mice had reduced lung volume compared to that of mice with optimal vitamin D
status. Vitamin D also appears to affect the development of the immune system
in utero. Chi et al [12] using data from the Urban Environment and Childhood
Asthma study, showed that vitamin D concentrations in cord blood were inversely
associated with the proportion of CD25 +, CD25 Bright and CD25 + FoxP3
regulatory T cells. After birth, vitamin D has immunomodulatory effects on the
allergen-induced inflammatory pathways by acting on the VDR expressed on
various immune cells, including B cells, T cells, dendritic cells and
macrophages [13,14]. Many of these cells, such as activated macrophages and
dendritic cells, are able to synthesize biologically active vitamin D from
circulating 25 OHD [15,16]. This mechanism allows immune cells to rapidly
increase local levels of vitamin D, which are potentially needed to shape
adaptive immune responses [17,18]. Low levels of vitamin D seem to be inversely
correlated with the severity of atopic dermatitis. Sharief et al have shown
that higher levels of IgE are associated with vitamin D deficiency in children
and adolescents [19]. Similarly, in another publication, mean serum 25 (OH) D
levels were lower in children with moderate to severe atopic dermatitis [20].
Which is consistent with our results. A small trial aimed to explore the impact
of vitamin D supplementation in the pediatric population on allergic diseases.
A study as part of a larger pilot study of vitamin D supplementation
investigated the effect of this supplementation on atopic dermatitis in 11
children [21]. The children were randomized to 1000 IU per day of
ergocalciferol or placebo for 1 month. There was a tendency to improve scores
for atopic dermatitis, but due to the small number and short duration of the
trial, the results were not statistically significant. Few studies have
investigated vitamin D status in allergic rhinitis and food allergy in children
[22]. May et al. [23] studied the relationship between the serum 25OHD level
and the incidence of allergic rhinitis. The study included a random sample of
the population (N = 1351), serum 25OHD levels <20 ng / ml were associated
with an increased risk of allergic rhinitis (OR adjusted to 2.55, p = 0.001),
these results are similar to ours. It has been suggested that a vitamin D
deficiency could alter the integrity of the epithelial barrier, which would
lead to increased and inappropriate exposure of the mucosa to food antigens as
well as an immune imbalance favoring sensitization, which would compromise
immunological tolerance. Therefore, early correction of vitamin D deficiency
could enhance mucosal defense, maintain healthy microbial ecology and tolerance
to allergens, and reduce the risk of food allergies in children. Mullins et al
[24] and Vassallo et al [25] reported significantly higher food allergy rates
in children born in autumn / winter, suggesting a relationship between food
allergy rates and monthly exposure to Sun. Two studies used data from the
National Health and Nutrition Survey (NHANES) conducted in the United States
[26,27]. In an analysis of 3136 children and adolescents, allergic
sensitization to 11 allergens was more frequent in those with a vitamin D
deficiency (<15 ng / ml) after a multivariate adjustment. Awareness included
food allergens (peanuts and shrimp), indoor allergens (dog, cockroach,
Alternaria sp) and pollen (oak, birch). The prevalence of vitamin D deficiency
in asthmatic and non-asthmatic children was determined in several case-control
studies, it varied considerably between the different studies ranging from 3%
to 77%, and moreover children without asthma had more vitamin D levels
sufficient compared to asthmatic children consistent with the results of our
study. Several studies have been carried out on African-American, [28] Qataris,
[29] Iranian children, [30] and all show that the prevalence of vitamin D
deficiency is higher in asthmatic children than in controls. Bener et al [31]
had carried out in 2012 a case-control study including 966 healthy children and
in asthmatics of equal age [32]. The authors found that vitamin D deficiency
was associated with an increased risk of asthma (adjusted OR: 4.82 CI:
2.4-8.6). Another analysis of 6,857 participants 6 years aged and older showed
that vitamin D levels were inversely associated with asthma [33]. Several
studies have studied the association between 25OHD and asthma exacerbations
measured in terms of hospitalizations and treatment with oral corticosteroids.
Except the study of Gergen, all studies have shown that a low serum vitamin D
concentration is associated with an increased risk of exacerbation of asthma
(RR = 0.64 CI: 0.5-0.8). Asthma control studies. Have evaluated control and
exacerbations based on the frequency of dosing and dosage of treatments, or the
number of emergencies. Brehm et al [34] correlated their data with vitamin D
concentrations. Gergen and Van Oeffelen found that a high serum 25OHD
concentration was associated with a reduction in the severity of asthma whereas
Chinellato and Gupta did not found any association. In the PIAMA birth cohort
of more than 300 children, serum vitamin D concentrations were inversely
associated with the prevalence of asthma in children from four to 8 years old
[35]. Hollams et al [36], in a cohort of more than 600 Australian children,
have shown that higher levels of vitamin D at 6 years protect against the
development of asthma, rhino-conjunctivitis and allergy. Several studies have
examined the relationship between vitamin D deficiency and exacerbations of
asthma [37]. Brehm et al were the first to show that vitamin D deficiency
(<30 ng / ml) was associated with an increased risk of severe asthma
exacerbations leading to emergency visits or hospitalizations after an analysis
of data collected from 1024 participants of the childhood asthma management
program (CAMP) [38]. Searing et al, in a cross-sectional study involving 100
asthmatic children, demonstrated inverse associations between vitamin D and
serum IgE levels, [39] the number of positive skin tests for pneumallergens,
lung function and use of corticosteroids by inhalation or orally. Other studies
have also shown that lower levels of vitamin D are associated with poorer lung
function and the presence of exercise-induced bronchoconstriction [40] in
children with asthma [41]. Bump et al [42] have shown in vitro that vitamin D
increases the bioavailability of glucocorticoids in bronchial smooth muscle
cells, suggesting an additional beneficial role of this vitamin in the
prevention and treatment of asthma. The role of vitamin D in preventing asthma
and allergies in children remains controversial. Although most of the published
data report a protective effect of higher vitamin D levels or vitamin D
consumption, some studies do not find this link. Thus, five prospective studies
on large cohorts evaluated the relationship between 25OHD levels and asthma,
and found no association. Other clinical trials would be useful to resolve
these inconsistencies [43].
The incidence of atopic manifestations varies significantly depending on vitamin D status in a population of young Algerian children. Vitamin D levels were lower in children who developed these conditions. Therefore, vitamin D deficiency would expose to the risk of the appearance of atopic manifestations. However, there is still much controversy about the role of vitamin D in allergic conditions. Large-scale randomized controlled trials are needed to better understand the effectiveness of vitamin D in children with atopic conditions. Future longitudinal and interventional cohort studies are needed to determine whether vitamin D supplementation could be used as a low-cost public health measure to reduce the incidence of asthma and atopy in children.
No conflict of interest.